Incorrect indentation when a comment line is placed right after a line without semicolon (JS Beautify)

[seoker]

If I have a line marked as comment under a normal statement without semicolon, like this

atom-beautify turns them to be

I'm wondering if this is a limitation or bug?

PS. For my team's coding convention, we don't use semicolon at the end of statements.

[Glavin001]

Could you run Atom command in command palette: Atom Beautify: Help Debug Editor, the put the contents into a Gist with a markdown file (extension .md) and paste the link here. Thanks,

[seoker]

Hi, I create a sample that shows this problem, not my original file.
Here is the link: https://gist.github.com/seoker/7e023d42715417c4811c

[prettydiff]

This looks like a Pretty Diff bug.

[seoker]

I'm using JS Beautify as default JS beautifier, not prettydiff, and the result is different from pretty diff.

original code:

JS beautify:

prettydiff:

[Glavin001]

If the beautifier is set to JS Beautify I recommend forwarding this issue over to them at https://github.com/beautify-web/js-beautify
When you create the issue there please link back to this issue so we can see if it is closed.

Also it looks like @prettydiff implemented the fix in Pretty Diff beautifier: prettydiff/prettydiff#138
So you could switch from JS Beautify to Pretty Diff for your Default Beautifier.

[prettydiff]

This issue is 2 years old. I am closing this issue as it is likely resolved. If the defect remains present please reopen this issue.