-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 0
/
Search (R1 - R2).html
92 lines (83 loc) · 15.5 KB
/
Search (R1 - R2).html
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
29
30
31
32
33
34
35
36
37
38
39
40
41
42
43
44
45
46
47
48
49
50
51
52
53
54
55
56
57
58
59
60
61
62
63
64
65
66
67
68
69
70
71
72
73
74
75
76
77
78
79
80
81
82
83
84
85
86
87
88
89
90
91
92
<h1 id="r1-select-papers-in-academic-literature">R1: Select papers in
academic literature</h1>
<p>TODO: rerun searches and note individual search terms!!!!!!</p>
<h2 id="search-criteria">Search criteria:</h2>
<ul>
<li>Abstracts, title, keywords</li>
<li>Abstracts in English</li>
<li>Only full papers (exclude conference proceedings, books and book
chapters, editorials)</li>
</ul>
<h2 id="databases">Databases</h2>
<p>I will use Scopus and Web Of Science, as they sometimes differ
significantly in the articles found.</p>
<h2 id="search-terms-general">Search terms general:</h2>
<pre><code>[About Transformative change] Transformative change synonyms
AND
[nature synonyms](use dictionary suggested by Aidin)
AND
(options/policy instruments)</code></pre>
<pre><code>("transformative change" OR "deliberate transformation*" OR "transformative turn*" OR "transition*” OR "social-ecological change*” OR "deep change” OR "fundamental alteration” OR "profound change” OR "profound transformation” OR "radical transformation” OR "transformational change” OR "complete change" OR "complete transformation” OR "drastic change” OR "in-depth transformation” OR "progressive change” OR "radical alteration” OR "radical change” OR "revolutionary change” OR "significant modification” OR "total transformation” OR "transformational shift” OR "radical shift”)
AND
("sustainab*" OR "environ*" OR "resilien*" OR "conserv*" OR "biodivers*" OR "ecosystem*” OR "nature*”)
AND
("act*" OR "option*" OR "polic*" OR "policies” OR "measure*" OR "agenda*" OR "gov*" OR "right" OR "val*" OR "power" OR "business approach*” OR "legal instrument*” OR "regulatory instrument*” OR "regulat*” OR "enforcement*” OR "standard*” OR "governance framework*” OR "method*” OR "decision-making*” OR "plan*” OR "strateg*” OR "evaluation*” OR "assessment*” OR "programm*” OR "connect*” OR "offset*” OR "permit*” OR "ban*” OR "restrict*” OR "control*” OR "education system*” OR ”education” OR "awareness*” OR "learning*” OR "knowledge system*” OR "conservation approach*” OR "restoration approach*” OR "monitoring” OR "inventor*” OR "coordination*” OR "civic action*” OR "collective action*”or "political action*” OR "community action*” OR "capacity building*” OR "pathway*” OR "scenario*” OR "model*” OR "solution*” OR "innovation*” OR "incentive*” OR "subsid*” OR "tax*” OR "payment*” OR "debt*” OR "aid*” OR "fiscal transfer*” OR "investment*” OR "financ*” OR "product*” OR "market*” OR "account*” OR "register*” OR "funding*” OR "consump*” OR "chain*” OR "certification*” OR "participatory process*” OR "deliberate process*” OR "pluralism” OR "agreement*” OR "cooperation” OR "demand*” OR "policy context*” OR "scheme*” OR "protect*” OR "conserv*”or "cultural arrangement*” OR "practice*” OR "technique*” OR "infrastructure*” OR "access” OR "trade-off*” OR "NBSAP*” OR "legislative control” OR "legal restriction” OR "derivative trading” OR "commodity futures” OR "social responsibility” OR "marine areas” OR "multilateral agreements” or”transparency” OR "litigation” OR "labelling” OR "OEAM” OR "co-management” OR "co-production" OR "co-creation" OR "recognition" OR "system*" OR "access rights" OR "legislative arrangements" OR "treaties" OR "rules" OR "culturally specific" OR "place-based" OR " mechanism" OR "method" OR "index" OR "indicators" OR "approach*" OR "perspective*" OR "valu*")</code></pre>
<h2 id="search-results">Search results</h2>
<p>Expected output: a list of papers that relate broadly to
transformative change AND nature AND options</p>
<h3 id="web-of-science---332188-hits"><a
href="https://www.webofscience.com/wos/alldb/summary/4784bd05-3f89-4ab3-b50b-3a94ec2bd264-95fca6fe/relevance/1">Web
of Science - 332,188 hits</a></h3>
<hr />
<h3 id="scopus---271521-hits"><a href="https://www.scopus.com/">Scopus -
271,521 hits</a></h3>
<h4 id="scopus-search-term">Scopus search term</h4>
<pre><code>TITLE-ABS-KEY (
( "transformative change" OR "deliberate transformation*" OR "transformative turn*" OR "transition*" OR "social-ecological change*" OR "deep change" OR "fundamental alteration" OR "profound change" OR "profound transformation" OR "radical transformation" OR "transformational change" OR "complete change" OR "complete transformation" OR "drastic change" OR "in-depth transformation" OR "progressive change" OR "radical alteration" OR "radical change" OR "revolutionary change" OR "significant modification" OR "total transformation" OR "transformational shift" OR "radical shift" )
AND
( "sustainab*" OR "environ*" OR "resilien*" OR "conserv*" OR "biodivers*" OR "ecosystem*" OR "nature*" )
AND
( "act*" OR "option*" OR "polic*" OR "policies" OR "measure*" OR "agenda*" OR "gov*" OR "right" OR "val*" OR "power" OR "business approach*" OR "legal instrument*" OR "regulatory instrument*" OR "regulat*" OR "enforcement*" OR "standard*" OR "governance framework*" OR "method*" OR "decision-making*" OR "plan*" OR "strateg*" OR "evaluation*" OR "assessment*" OR "programm*" OR "connect*" OR "offset*" OR "permit*" OR "ban*" OR "restrict*" OR "control*" OR "education system*" OR "education" OR "awareness*" OR "learning*" OR "knowledge system*" OR "conservation approach*" OR "restoration approach*" OR "monitoring" OR "inventor*" OR "coordination*" OR "civic action*" OR "collective action*" OR "political action*" OR "community action*" OR "capacity building*" OR "pathway*" OR "scenario*" OR "model*" OR "solution*" OR "innovation*" OR "incentive*" OR "subsid*" OR "tax*" OR "payment*" OR "debt*" OR "aid*" OR "fiscal transfer*" OR "investment*" OR "financ*" OR "product*" OR "market*" OR "account*" OR "register*" OR "funding*" OR "consump*" OR "chain*" OR "certification*" OR "participatory process*" OR "deliberate process*" OR "pluralism" OR "agreement*" OR "cooperation" OR "demand*" OR "policy context*" OR "scheme*" OR "protect*" OR "conserv*" OR "cultural arrangement*" OR "practice*" OR "technique*" OR "infrastructure*" OR "access" OR "trade-off*" OR "NBSAP*" OR "legislative control" OR "legal restriction" OR "derivative trading" OR "commodity futures" OR "social responsibility" OR "marine areas" OR "multilateral agreements" OR "transparency" OR "litigation" OR "labelling" OR "OEAM" OR "co-management" OR "co-production" OR "co-creation" OR "recognition" OR "system*" OR "access rights" OR "legislative arrangements" OR "treaties" OR "rules" OR "culturally specific" OR "place-based" OR " mechanism" OR "method" OR "index" OR "indicators" OR "approach*" OR "perspective*" OR "valu*" )
)
AND
( LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE , "ar" ) OR LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE , "re" ) ) </code></pre>
<h1
id="r2-screen-for-papers-with-concrete-examples-e.g.-case-studies-implementation-example">R2:
Screen for papers with concrete examples (e.g., case-studies,
“implementation”, “example*”)</h1>
<h2 id="search-criteria-1">Search Criteria</h2>
<p>Sub-sample of R1 corpus, search in abstracts, title, keywords</p>
<h2 id="additional-search-terms">Additional search terms</h2>
<p>The search will be re-run, adding the additional search terms as an
<code>AND</code> condition.</p>
<pre><code>("case stud*” or "case” or "study area*” or "example*” or "evaluation” or "solutions” or "implementation”or "concrete” or "empirical”, or "practical”)</code></pre>
<h2 id="corpus-a-academic-articles-with-specific-examples">Corpus A:
academic articles with specific examples</h2>
<h3 id="web-of-science---87642-of-previously-332079-hits"><a
href="https://www.webofscience.com/wos/alldb/summary/fa21ebb9-347c-4fca-a0cf-e07fb55b0a43-95fce149/relevance/1">Web
of Science - 87,642 of previously 332,079 hits</a></h3>
<h3 id="scopus---85624-of-previously-271521-hits"><a
href="https://www.scopus.com/">Scopus - 85,624 of previously 271,521
hits</a></h3>
<h4 id="search-term">Search term</h4>
<pre><code>TITLE-ABS-KEY (
(
( "transformative change" OR "deliberate transformation*" OR "transformative turn*" OR "transition*" OR "social-ecological change*" OR "deep change" OR "fundamental alteration" OR "profound change" OR "profound transformation" OR "radical transformation" OR "transformational change" OR "complete change" OR "complete transformation" OR "drastic change" OR "in-depth transformation" OR "progressive change" OR "radical alteration" OR "radical change" OR "revolutionary change" OR "significant modification" OR "total transformation" OR "transformational shift" OR "radical shift" )
AND
( "sustainab*" OR "environ*" OR "resilien*" OR "conserv*" OR "biodivers*" OR "ecosystem*" OR "nature*" )
AND
( "act*" OR "option*" OR "polic*" OR "policies" OR "measure*" OR "agenda*" OR "gov*" OR "right" OR "val*" OR "power" OR "business approach*" OR "legal instrument*" OR "regulatory instrument*" OR "regulat*" OR "enforcement*" OR "standard*" OR "governance framework*" OR "method*" OR "decision-making*" OR "plan*" OR "strateg*" OR "evaluation*" OR "assessment*" OR "programm*" OR "connect*" OR "offset*" OR "permit*" OR "ban*" OR "restrict*" OR "control*" OR "education system*" OR "education" OR "awareness*" OR "learning*" OR "knowledge system*" OR "conservation approach*" OR "restoration approach*" OR "monitoring" OR "inventor*" OR "coordination*" OR "civic action*" OR "collective action*" OR "political action*" OR "community action*" OR "capacity building*" OR "pathway*" OR "scenario*" OR "model*" OR "solution*" OR "innovation*" OR "incentive*" OR "subsid*" OR "tax*" OR "payment*" OR "debt*" OR "aid*" OR "fiscal transfer*" OR "investment*" OR "financ*" OR "product*" OR "market*" OR "account*" OR "register*" OR "funding*" OR "consump*" OR "chain*" OR "certification*" OR "participatory process*" OR "deliberate process*" OR "pluralism" OR "agreement*" OR "cooperation" OR "demand*" OR "policy context*" OR "scheme*" OR "protect*" OR "conserv*" OR "cultural arrangement*" OR "practice*" OR "technique*" OR "infrastructure*" OR "access" OR "trade-off*" OR "NBSAP*" OR "legislative control" OR "legal restriction" OR "derivative trading" OR "commodity futures" OR "social responsibility" OR "marine areas" OR "multilateral agreements" OR "transparency" OR "litigation" OR "labelling" OR "OEAM" OR "co-management" OR "co-production" OR "co-creation" OR "recognition" OR "system*" OR "access rights" OR "legislative arrangements" OR "treaties" OR "rules" OR "culturally specific" OR "place-based" OR " mechanism" OR "method" OR "index" OR "indicators" OR "approach*" OR "perspective*" OR "valu*" )
)
AND
(
( "case stud*" OR "case" OR "study area*" OR "example*" OR "evaluation" OR "solutions" OR "implementation" OR "concrete" OR "empirical" OR "practical" )
)
)
AND
( LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE , "ar" ) OR LIMIT-TO ( DOCTYPE , "re" ) ) </code></pre>
<h1 id="corpus-b-academic-articles-not-in-corpus-a">Corpus B: academic
articles not in Corpus A</h1>
<p>These do relate to transformative change, nature and options but do
not provide information from a specific case (e.g., general
recommendations, overviews).</p>
<p>The corpus is the corpus from R1 excluding the corpus from R2</p>