Unable to withdraw rewards. "Illegal Value in TxOut"

[vshybalov]

Description

I am unable to create transaction with cardano-cli 9.4.1.0, 10.1.1.0 to withdraw rewards. The last working version was cardano-cli 9.2.1.0.

Steps to Reproduce

The amount in variable below is 2276043199 without any negative symbols.

cardano-cli conway transaction build --mainnet --witness-override 2 --tx-in ${TXIN} --withdrawal "${STAKE_ADDRESS}+${REWARDS_AMOUNT}" --tx-out "${DSTADDRESS}+${REWARDS_AMOUNT}" --change-address ${ADDRESS} --out-file tx.raw

cardano-cli: Illegal Value in TxOut: MaryValue (Coin (-1272733348)) (MultiAsset (fromList []))
CallStack (from HasCallStack):
  error, called at src/Cardano/Ledger/Babbage/TxOut.hs:401:25 in cardano-ledger-babbage-1.9.0.0-Ek1rsoJwqvmCy8NgTgKsxr:Cardano.Ledger.Babbage.TxOut
  mkTxOut, called at src/Cardano/Ledger/Babbage/TxOut.hs:372:44 in cardano-ledger-babbage-1.9.0.0-Ek1rsoJwqvmCy8NgTgKsxr:Cardano.Ledger.Babbage.TxOut
  BabbageTxOut, called at src/Cardano/Ledger/Conway/TxOut.hs:40:26 in cardano-ledger-conway-1.16.2.0-4XQSafjZx8OK5CVEBZ7pWD:Cardano.Ledger.Conway.TxOut
  mkBasicTxOut, called at internal/Cardano/Api/Tx/Body.hs:3084:13 in cardano-api-9.3.0.0-C0QPA7dowbsCao5S5QVkzf-internal:Cardano.Api.Tx.Body
  toShelleyTxOutAny, called at internal/Cardano/Api/Tx/Body.hs:2339:41 in cardano-api-9.3.0.0-C0QPA7dowbsCao5S5QVkzf-internal:Cardano.Api.Tx.Body

Additional Context

There were no issues, before the new versions of cli, in terms of rewards claiming, nothing changed on our end.

Possible Solution

[carbolymer]

It's not quite obvious where did the value (Coin (-1272733348)) come from. Could you provide full reproduction command with concrete values and addresses instead of shell variables?

[vshybalov]

Hello @carbolymer

Please see below the latest attempt with all the values unhidden.

cardano-cli version 
cardano-cli 10.1.1.0 - linux-x86_64 - ghc-8.10
git rev 01bda2e2cb0a70cd95067d696dbb44665f1d680a

cardano-cli conway transaction build --mainnet --witness-override 2 --tx-in da8795bba4f4549b7987aac5ae240f941d2ebb93fa15eb288987851ef73b241e#1 --withdrawal stake1uxc2mze08jpandr4552xscp4vs2spe5uqeyt8jyjq3ynydcu0l6c2+2695208894 --tx-out Ae2tdPwUPEYzuiAjQwyVoweSXt9KzX3jxw4vPpCTv3Bi7o134EdPdNsbiaW+2695208894 --change-address addr1qyc9q2juznjj52hujclkt37xt99nt9p3zcys9wwkf6mlp89s4k9j70yrmx68tfg5dpsr2eq4qrnfcpjgk0yfypzfxgms22rwuh --out-file tx.raw

cardano-cli: Illegal Value in TxOut: MaryValue (Coin (-1694702387)) (MultiAsset (fromList []))
CallStack (from HasCallStack):
  error, called at src/Cardano/Ledger/Babbage/TxOut.hs:401:25 in cardano-ledger-babbage-1.10.0.0-oRnre4HZULFAKhFSl9oK6:Cardano.Ledger.Babbage.TxOut
  mkTxOut, called at src/Cardano/Ledger/Babbage/TxOut.hs:372:44 in cardano-ledger-babbage-1.10.0.0-oRnre4HZULFAKhFSl9oK6:Cardano.Ledger.Babbage.TxOut
  BabbageTxOut, called at src/Cardano/Ledger/Conway/TxOut.hs:40:26 in cardano-ledger-conway-1.17.2.0-DjShi1w51BjCHAy5SUbvk1:Cardano.Ledger.Conway.TxOut
  mkBasicTxOut, called at internal/Cardano/Api/Tx/Body.hs:3148:13 in cardano-api-10.1.0.0-Gk2qtfoAiA71gJjiX7o8yh-internal:Cardano.Api.Tx.Body
  toShelleyTxOutAny, called at internal/Cardano/Api/Tx/Body.hs:2400:41 in cardano-api-10.1.0.0-Gk2qtfoAiA71gJjiX7o8yh-internal:Cardano.Api.Tx.Body

[carbolymer]

Possible duplicate of:

• Negative values are not checked when building tx and ledger exception is returned #904

I think the fix is on its way to get integrated to cardano-cli:

• Parameterize Value parser on role of the Value being parsed: transaction output or minting policy cardano-api#666

[vshybalov]

@carbolymer

The only difference with the #904 issue, is that there -1 value in the arguments. However in my case there is no negative values, so it is interesting where cli take that negative number from.

[carbolymer]

@vshybalov Ah right, good catch. Yes indeed it looks different. Most likely related to autobalancing.