diff --git a/Scripts/SL-PlayerProfiles.lua b/Scripts/SL-PlayerProfiles.lua
index f8e2c22a0..4f6f31322 100644
--- a/Scripts/SL-PlayerProfiles.lua
+++ b/Scripts/SL-PlayerProfiles.lua
@@ -162,11 +162,8 @@ SaveProfileCustom = function(profile, dir)
 			IniFile.WriteFile( path, {[theme_name]=output} )
 
 			-- Write to the ITL file if we need to.
-			-- The ITLData table will only contain data for memory cards.
-			if #SL[pn].ITLData ~= 0 then
-				WriteItlFile(dir, table.concat(SL[pn].ITLData, ""))
-			end
-
+			-- This is relevant for memory cards.
+			WriteItlFile(player)
 			break
 		end
 	end
diff --git a/Scripts/SL_ITL.lua b/Scripts/SL_ITL.lua
index c78babe3d..a3a6ed722 100644
--- a/Scripts/SL_ITL.lua
+++ b/Scripts/SL_ITL.lua
@@ -43,16 +43,30 @@ end
 -- Note that songs resynced for ITL but played outside of the pack will not be covered in the pathMap.
 local itlFilePath = "itl2023.json"
 
+local TableContainsData = function(t)
+	if t == nil then return false end
+
+	for _, _ in pairs(t) do
+			return true
+	end
+	return false
+end
 
 -- Takes the ITLData loaded in memory and writes it to the local profile.
 WriteItlFile = function(player)
+	local pn = ToEnumShortString(player)
+	-- No data to write, return early.
+	if (not TableContainsData(SL[pn].ITLData["pathMap"]) and
+			not TableContainsData(SL[pn].ITLData["hashMap"])) then
+		return
+	end
+
 	local profile_slot = {
 		[PLAYER_1] = "ProfileSlot_Player1",
 		[PLAYER_2] = "ProfileSlot_Player2"
 	}
 	
 	local dir = PROFILEMAN:GetProfileDir(profile_slot[player])
-	local pn = ToEnumShortString(player)
 	-- We require an explicit profile to be loaded.
 	if not dir or #dir == 0 then return end