diff --git a/src/main/java/at/hannibal2/skyhanni/features/inventory/ItemDisplayOverlayFeatures.kt b/src/main/java/at/hannibal2/skyhanni/features/inventory/ItemDisplayOverlayFeatures.kt
index fa3724bcab7e..3aa5beaa2d85 100644
--- a/src/main/java/at/hannibal2/skyhanni/features/inventory/ItemDisplayOverlayFeatures.kt
+++ b/src/main/java/at/hannibal2/skyhanni/features/inventory/ItemDisplayOverlayFeatures.kt
@@ -23,6 +23,7 @@ import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.config.features.inventory.InventoryConfig.ItemNumbe
 import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.config.features.inventory.InventoryConfig.ItemNumberEntry.VACUUM_GARDEN
 import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.data.PetAPI
 import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.events.RenderItemTipEvent
+import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.features.garden.GardenAPI
 import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.features.garden.pests.PestAPI
 import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.features.skillprogress.SkillType
 import at.hannibal2.skyhanni.utils.ConfigUtils
@@ -183,13 +184,15 @@ object ItemDisplayOverlayFeatures {
 
         if (RANCHERS_BOOTS_SPEED.isSelected() && internalName == "RANCHERS_BOOTS".asInternalName()) {
             item.getRanchersSpeed()?.let {
-                return if (it > 400 && !(PetAPI.isCurrentPet("Black Cat") ||
-                        InventoryUtils.getHelmet()?.getInternalName() == "RACING_HELMET".asInternalName())
-                ) {
-                    "§c$it"
-                } else {
-                    "§a$it"
-                }
+                val isUsingBlackCat = PetAPI.isCurrentPet("Black Cat")
+                val helmet = InventoryUtils.getHelmet()?.getInternalName()
+                val hand = InventoryUtils.getItemInHand()?.getInternalName()
+                val racingHelmet = "RACING_HELMET".asInternalName()
+                val cactusKnife = "CACTUS_KNIFE".asInternalName()
+                val is500 = isUsingBlackCat || helmet == racingHelmet || (GardenAPI.inGarden() && hand == cactusKnife)
+                val effectiveSpeedCap = if (is500) 500 else 400
+                val text = if (it > 999) "1k" else "$it"
+                return if (it > effectiveSpeedCap) "§c$text" else "§a$text"
             }
         }