Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Combine IGT translations as <gloss type="igt"> with grammar in value of <span type="gram"> #93

Open
iljackb opened this issue Nov 3, 2019 · 0 comments

Comments

@iljackb
Copy link
Owner

iljackb commented Nov 3, 2019

As per the discussion on issue #91, I need to decide whether to combine the annotations of IGT with those of grammar.

Rather than doing the following and creating duplicate content (which is time consuming and redundant)....

               <spanGrp type="annotations">
                  .....
                  <span type="gram" target="#d1e200" ana="#V #INTRANS #INCOMPL">
                  <span type="igt" target="#d1e200">go</span>

                  <span type="gram"  target="#d1e202" ana="#ENCLTC #3PERS #SG #ANML"/>
                  <span type="igt" target="#d1e202">3sg.anml</span>

                  <span target="#d1e204" xml:lang="en">up to</span>
                  <span target="#d1e204" xml:lang="es">hasta</span>
                  <span type="gram" target="#d1e204" ana="#ADPOS"/>
                  <span type="igt" target="#d1e204">up.to</span>

                  <span type="translation"  target="#d1e206" xml:lang="en">where</span>
                  <span type="translation"  target="#d1e206" xml:lang="es">dónde</span>
                  <span type="gram" target="#d1e206" ana="#ADPOS"/>
                  <span type="igt" target="#d1e206">face</span>

                  <span type="translation" target="#d1e208" xml:lang="en" type="inflected">are sitting</span>
                  <span type="translation" target="#d1e208" xml:lang="es" type="inflected">están</span>
                  <span type="gram" target="#d1e208" ana="#V #INTRANS #INCOMPL"/>
                  <span type="igt" target="#d1e208">sit</span>

                  <span type="translation" target="#d1e210" xml:lang="en">tortilla</span>
                  <span type="translation" target="#d1e210" xml:lang="es">tortilla</span>
                  <span type="gram" target="#d1e210" ana="#N"/>
                  <span type="igt" target="#d1e210">tortilla</span>
               </spanGrp> 

...it would be more efficient to combine the two and put the IGT in the value of the <span type="gram"> element given that the given content will be annotated anyway.. Thus I would propose to do the following:

            <spanGrp type="annotations" resp="#JB">
              ...
               <span type="gram" target="#d1e200" ana="#V #INTRANS"><gloss type="igt">go</gloss></span>
               <span type="gram" target="#d1e202" ana="#ENCLTC #3PERS #SG #ANML"><gloss type="igt">3sg.anml</gloss></span>
              ...
               <span type="gram" target="#d1e204" ana="#ADPOS"><gloss type="igt">up.to</gloss></span>
              ...
               <span type="gram" target="#d1e206" ana="#ADPOS"><gloss type="igt">face</gloss></span>
              ...
               <span type="gram" target="#d1e208" ana="#V #INTRANS #INCOMPL"><gloss type="igt">sit</gloss></span>
              ...
               <span type="gram" target="#d1e210" ana="#N"><gloss type="igt">tortilla</gloss></span>
            </spanGrp>

Ideally, I'd like to use @notation for specifying interlinear-glossed text since it is an annotation standard, I could do this in the ODD and maybe propose a ticket too...

@laurent what do you think?

This was referenced Nov 3, 2019
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

No branches or pull requests

1 participant