Fragment transaction breaks layout if exitUntilCollapsed flag is set

[mikhailmelnik]

Description:
The pretty much standard layout of

CoordinatorLayout
    AppBarLayout
        CollapsingToolbarLayout [app:layout_scrollFlags="scroll|snap|exitUntilCollapsed"]
            Toolbar
NestedScrollView [app:layout_behavior="@string/appbar_scrolling_view_behavior"]

in fragment works pretty well until fragment transaction happens (e.g. switch to another fragment and come back).

With no exitUntilCollapsed flag set original fragment got restored as it should keeping the scroll position etc. But if this flag is set various issues happen after the fragment transaction including scroll position reset (sometimes) and (pretty much always) inability to move scrolled content (including overscroll effect) to the view port.

Removal of exitUntilCollapsed flag makes the whole thing work again but at the price of Toolbar visibility.

Source code:
https://github.com/material-components/material-components-android/blob/master/catalog/java/io/material/catalog/tableofcontents/res/layout/cat_toc_fragment.xml

Android API version:
23

Material Library version:
master branch

Device:
LG G3

Demo:
After I've switched to another fragment and came back the part of content ("Transitions" label, overscroll etc) became unavailable:

[lvcmenezes]

Same problem here, did you manage to find a fix for it?

[mikhailmelnik]

@lvcmenezes nope, and I wonder how does world live with that without any complain.

[mikhailmelnik]

@lvcmenezes looks like I found a workaround, not sure though if it works in all circumstances:

override fun onCreateView(inflater: LayoutInflater, container: ViewGroup?, savedInstanceState: Bundle?): View? {
    val view = ...
    view.postDelayed(0) { view.requestLayout() }
    return view
}

[mikhailmelnik]

@chrisbanes could be this issue related the issue you've fixed with #299 ?

[mariuspena]

I have almost the same issue. I have tried version 1.1.0, and 1.2.0-alpha06

See video:
https://youtu.be/Q_LaMnwhOyU

1. 1st view: a Fragment that has CoordinatorLayout, it scrolls fine.
2. go to another activity (same setup.. )
   2.1. if I do not touch any view in the activity and go back, the fragment scrolls fine
   2.2. if I focus on an EditText, or click on a Button and then go back > the header scrolls, the content stays in the same place.

PS: since the 1st view (the fragment) is part of a Navigation (with NavHostFragment and BottomNavigationView) ... sometimes the other fragments have 0 width and height (so a blank page.. although the api calls work, recyclers are populated, etc)

[mikhailmelnik]

Fixed by a21a300

[crocsandcoffee]

I don't believe this issue has been fixed yet. I am using the layout below:

<CoordinatorLayout

    <RecyclerView app:layout_behavior="@string/appbar_scrolling_view_behavior"
    
    <AppBarLayout
     
        <CollapsingToolbarLayout app:layout_scrollFlags="scroll|exitUntilCollapsed"
    

and let's say the toolbar is in collapsed state, and user has scrolled somewhere in the list, taps a list item and navigates to another fragment. Hitting back, the fragment transaction is reversed, and upon returning to this fragment, the collapsing toolbar is in expanded state but scroll pos in recycler view has been retained. it almost looks like the Collapsing toolbar expands as the fragment is exiting, so when returning to it, it's now in expanded state.

I tested with version 1.3.0-rc01 which was tagged above as having a commit that fixes this issue.

[OhhhThatVarun]

Yes, it is not fixed. I tested it with 1.13.0-alpha02. I'm having the same issue as @crocsandcoffee. The CollapsingToolbarLayout just doesn't stay collapsed.