diff --git a/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp b/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp
index d243f7517a5..a2c2cf26d8a 100644
--- a/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp
+++ b/src/cascadia/LocalTests_TerminalApp/SettingsTests.cpp
@@ -1280,11 +1280,11 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
                     "guid": "{6239a42c-6666-49a3-80bd-e8fdd045185c}"
                 },
                 {
-                    "name" : "Ubuntu",
-                    "guid" : "{2C4DE342-38B7-51CF-B940-2309A097F518}"
+                    "name" : "ThisProfileShouldNotThrow"
                 },
                 {
-                    "name" : "ThisProfileShouldNotCrash"
+                    "name" : "Ubuntu",
+                    "guid" : "{2C4DE342-38B7-51CF-B940-2309A097F518}"
                 }
             ]
         })" };
@@ -1292,11 +1292,13 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
         auto name0{ L"profile0" };
         auto name1{ L"profile1" };
         auto name2{ L"Ubuntu" };
+        auto name3{ L"ThisProfileShouldNotThrow" };
         auto badName{ L"DoesNotExist" };
 
         auto guid0{ Microsoft::Console::Utils::GuidFromString(L"{6239a42c-5555-49a3-80bd-e8fdd045185c}") };
         auto guid1{ Microsoft::Console::Utils::GuidFromString(L"{6239a42c-6666-49a3-80bd-e8fdd045185c}") };
         auto guid2{ Microsoft::Console::Utils::GuidFromString(L"{2C4DE342-38B7-51CF-B940-2309A097F518}") };
+        auto fakeGuid{ Microsoft::Console::Utils::GuidFromString(L"{FFFFFFFF-FFFF-FFFF-FFFF-FFFFFFFFFFFF}") };
         std::optional<GUID> badGuid{};
 
         VerifyParseSucceeded(settings0String);
@@ -1308,22 +1310,19 @@ namespace TerminalAppLocalTests
         VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(guid0, settings.FindGuid(name0));
         VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(guid1, settings.FindGuid(name1));
         VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(guid2, settings.FindGuid(name2));
+        VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(badGuid, settings.FindGuid(name3));
         VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(badGuid, settings.FindGuid(badName));
-        // Following test will fail because GetGuid throws (despite being noexcept)
-        // VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(badGuid, settings.FindGuid(L"ThisProfileShouldNotCrash"));
 
-        // Following lines only work because the GUID-less profile is last
         auto prof0{ settings.FindProfile(guid0) };
         auto prof1{ settings.FindProfile(guid1) };
         auto prof2{ settings.FindProfile(guid2) };
-        // Following line will fail because GetGuid throws (despite being noexcept)
-        // auto badProf{ settings.FindProfile(badGuid) };
+
+        auto badProf{ settings.FindProfile(fakeGuid) };
+        VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(badProf, nullptr);
 
         VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(name0, prof0->GetName());
         VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(name1, prof1->GetName());
         VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(name2, prof2->GetName());
-        // Following test will fail because GetGuid throws (despite being noexcept)
-        // VERIFY_ARE_EQUAL(badName, badProf->GetName());
     }
 
     void SettingsTests::TestLayerGlobalsOnRoot()
diff --git a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/CascadiaSettings.cpp b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/CascadiaSettings.cpp
index a8058267c53..629d0007c2f 100644
--- a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/CascadiaSettings.cpp
+++ b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/CascadiaSettings.cpp
@@ -78,7 +78,12 @@ std::optional<GUID> CascadiaSettings::FindGuid(const std::wstring& profileName)
     {
         if (profileName == profile.GetName())
         {
-            profileGuid = profile.GetGuid();
+            try
+            {
+                profileGuid = profile.GetGuid();
+            }
+            CATCH_LOG();
+
             break;
         }
     }
@@ -98,10 +103,14 @@ const Profile* CascadiaSettings::FindProfile(GUID profileGuid) const noexcept
 {
     for (auto& profile : _profiles)
     {
-        if (profile.GetGuid() == profileGuid)
+        try
         {
-            return &profile;
+            if (profile.GetGuid() == profileGuid)
+            {
+                return &profile;
+            }
         }
+        CATCH_LOG();
     }
     return nullptr;
 }
diff --git a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.cpp b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.cpp
index d689bc6c7be..788e2b6db5d 100644
--- a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.cpp
+++ b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.cpp
@@ -138,7 +138,7 @@ bool Profile::HasSource() const noexcept
     return _source.has_value();
 }
 
-GUID Profile::GetGuid() const noexcept
+GUID Profile::GetGuid() const
 {
     // This can throw if we never had our guid set to a legitimate value.
     THROW_HR_IF_MSG(E_FAIL, !_guid.has_value(), "Profile._guid always expected to have a value");
diff --git a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.h b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.h
index 7f42641cb49..ba85b977c2e 100644
--- a/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.h
+++ b/src/cascadia/TerminalApp/Profile.h
@@ -64,7 +64,7 @@ class TerminalApp::Profile final
 
     bool HasGuid() const noexcept;
     bool HasSource() const noexcept;
-    GUID GetGuid() const noexcept;
+    GUID GetGuid() const;
     void SetSource(std::wstring_view sourceNamespace) noexcept;
     std::wstring_view GetName() const noexcept;
     bool HasConnectionType() const noexcept;