Rule proposal: prefer-queue-microtask

[kevinoid]

queueMicrotask() serves a similar purpose to process.nextTick() with the additional advantage that queueMicrotask() is specified in the WHATWG HTML Living Standard and supported on both modern browsers and Node.js (v11.0.0 and later).

When to use queueMicrotask() vs. process.nextTick() in the Node.js API documentation states:

For most userland use cases, the queueMicrotask() API provides a portable and reliable mechanism for deferring execution that works across multiple JavaScript platform environments and should be favored over process.nextTick(). In simple scenarios, queueMicrotask() can be a drop-in replacement for process.nextTick().

I propose adding a rule to warn when process.nextTick is used, and suggest queueMicrotask() as an alternative.

Fail

process.nextTick(() => process.exit(0));

process.nextTick(process.exit);

process.nextTick(process.exit, 1);

const fun = process.nextTick;

fun(process.nextTick);

Pass

queueMicrotask(() => process.exit(0));

queueMicrotask(process.exit);

// Note: queueMicrotask takes exactly 1 arg.
// Fail example fixed using .bind().
queueMicrotask(process.exit.bind(undefined, 1));

// Not sure if this should be auto-fixed.
// fun may be called with multiple args.
const fun = queueMicrotask;

// Not sure if this should be auto-fixed.
// fun may call its argument with multiple args.
fun(process.nextTick);

[fisker]

I never used process.nextTick in Node.js, but in browser, I used setTimeout setImmediate requestAnimationFrame MutationObserver Promise#then to do similar thing.

[sindresorhus]

https://www.freecodecamp.org/news/the-differences-between-javascripts-asynchronous-api-timers-d916e0596716/

https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/API/HTML_DOM_API/Microtask_guide

[kevinoid]

Good points. Lots of APIs with subtle differences. I've also used those at different times, or for different purposes. It's complicated.

@fisker Any reservations about a rule to prefer queueMicrotask() to process.nextTick() specifically? Or are you considering a rule to prefer any of the others? In either case, I'd be happy to discuss the differences and work through the details.

[fisker]

What I was saying, I think queueMicrotask should be preferred, but check process.nextTick is not going to help me at all.

[sindresorhus]

I never used process.nextTick in Node.js, but in browser, I used setTimeout setImmediate requestAnimationFrame MutationObserver Promise#then to do similar thing.

I will try to summarize the differences as far as I know it:

• setTimeout(..., 0) executes at the end of the event loop run (after all tasks).
• setImmediate() executes after all I/O tasks.
• requestAnimationFrame is about rendering.
• MutationObserver is for DOM mutatations, but has been used as a hack to get the same behavior as queueMicrotask.
• Promise#then does almost the same as queueMicrotask as it adds the callback to the micro-task queue.

[sindresorhus]

We could support Promise#then, but it will conflict with rules enforcing await. And when used with await it solves a different problem:

(async () => {
	// Cannot use `queueMicrotask` here.
	await ''; // Defer a micro-task tick.

	console.log('Hello');
})();

[sindresorhus]

setTimeout and setImmediate works differently, so changing to queueMicrotask might cause weird bugs or not be possible at all. We could potentially add an option to make it opt-in.

[sindresorhus]

Ideally, we would have a rule prefer-set-immediate which would prefer it over setTimeout(..., 0), but setImmediate doesn't work in the browser, so it's not a good API to use.

[sindresorhus]

Seems like we'll eventually get another alternative, so we can put this rule on hold until it's a reality:

• scheduler.yield(): https://github.com/WICG/scheduling-apis
• timers: add experimental scheduler api nodejs/node#40909

[sindresorhus]

Seems like we'll eventually get another alternative, so we can put this rule on hold until it's a reality:

Doesn't look like it will happen anytime soon, so this is now accepted. Let's start with preferring queueMicrotask over process.nextTick, with opt in to also enforce for setImmediate and setTimeout..., 0).