Evaluate ulidx as ulid replacement

[frytg]

The original ulid is no longer maintained, and has several outstanding compatibility-related issues that were never addressed. This library aims to address those and remain compatible in a larger range of environments.

options:

• https://jsr.io/@std/ulid / https://github.com/denoland/std/tree/main/ulid
• https://www.npmjs.com/package/ulidx / https://github.com/perry-mitchell/ulidx

[frytg]

(there also another ulid package on jsr, as part of @std https://jsr.io/@std/ulid)

[frytg]

To compare the ULID (Universally Unique Lexicographically Sortable Identifier) packages for JavaScript, we can look at several factors such as features, performance, ease of use, and community support. Here's a breakdown of each package:

1. Deno Standard Library ULID

• Environment: Specifically designed for Deno, a modern runtime for JavaScript and TypeScript.
• Features:
  • Provides a simple API for generating and parsing ULIDs.
  • Designed to integrate seamlessly with other Deno standard modules.
• Performance: Optimized for Deno, which may offer performance benefits in Deno-specific environments.
• Ease of Use: Easy to use within the Deno ecosystem, but not directly usable in Node.js without modifications.
• Community Support: Part of the Deno standard library, so it benefits from the support of the Deno community.

2. ulidx

• Environment: Node.js and browser environments.
• Features:
  • Aims to be a simple and lightweight implementation.
  • Provides both synchronous and asynchronous ULID generation.
  • Includes additional utilities for working with ULIDs.
• Performance: Focuses on lightweight and efficient operations, suitable for both server and client-side applications.
• Ease of Use: Simple API makes it easy to integrate into projects.
• Community Support: Smaller community compared to more established libraries, but actively maintained.

3. ulid/javascript

• Environment: Node.js and browser environments.
• Features:
  • One of the original and most popular ULID implementations.
  • Provides a robust and battle-tested API for generating ULIDs.
  • Offers options for customizing time and randomness sources.
• Performance: Highly optimized and widely used, ensuring reliability and speed.
• Ease of Use: Well-documented and easy to integrate, with a straightforward API.
• Community Support: Large community and extensive use in various projects, leading to quick support and updates.

Summary

• Deno Standard Library ULID: Best if you are working exclusively within the Deno ecosystem.
• ulidx: Good choice for lightweight applications needing both sync and async operations in Node.js or browser environments.
• ulid/javascript: Ideal for most use cases due to its maturity, community support, and flexibility in both Node.js and browser environments.

When choosing a package, consider your specific environment and requirements, such as the need for browser support or integration with Deno.