[Bug]: 开启了 COMMENT_AUDIT 审核评论后，首次提交的时候评论还是会显示出来 || [Bug]: After turning on COMMENT_AUDIT to review comments, the comments will still be displayed when submitting for the first time.

[luobogor]

问题描述 | Describe the bug

开启了 COMMENT_AUDIT 为 true 设置评论审核。但是提交的时候评论还是会显示出来，要刷新一下页面评论才会消失。实际上提交之后我希望通过一次 toast 让用户知道已经成功，让他等审核就可以。现在这样显示出来可能会让用户误以为评论成功，然后刷新页面一看又没了就很奇怪。能不能加多一个配置让开发者自己决定要不要马上显示评论。

问题网站 | Website URL

https://indiehackertools.net/tools/free-for-dev

服务部署在哪里？ | Where your waline deploy?

Vercel (Default)

数据存储在哪里？| Where your comment data store?

LeanCloud(https://leancloud.app)

---

Problem description | Describe the bug

Enable COMMENT_AUDIT to true to set comment moderation. However, the comments will still be displayed when submitting, and the comments will disappear after refreshing the page. In fact, after submitting, I hope to let the user know that it has been successful through a toast and let him wait for review. Displaying it like this now may make users mistakenly think that the comment is successful, and then refresh the page and see that it is gone again, which is very strange. Can you add another configuration to let developers decide whether to display comments immediately?

Question Website | Website URL

https://indiehackertools.net/tools/free-for-dev

Where is the service deployed? | Where your waline deploy?

Vercel (Default)

Where is the data stored? | Where your comment data store?

LeanCloud(https://leancloud.app)

[lizheming]

现在这个交互主要是前台插入的，用这个交互来表示评论发布成功。你说的这种交互也是可以的，但盲目的选择了你的这种交互，可能会导致习惯了之前的交互的同学又有疑惑。所以官方客户端可能需要等更多类似的反馈出来之后再考虑处理，暂时还不会去修改这个交互。

针对你的问题，你有以下几个方案：

1. 开启强制登录评论。当前登录的用户的评论，即使是在审核状态，也是会给用户展示的。这样可以规避刷新一下就没有了的问题。
2. 自行 fork 官方客户端，修改这块的交互

---

Now this interaction is mainly inserted in the front desk, and this interaction is used to indicate that the comment has been published successfully. The kind of interaction you mentioned is also possible, but blindly choosing your kind of interaction may cause confusion among students who are used to previous interactions. Therefore, the official client may need to wait for more similar feedback before considering processing it, and will not modify this interaction for the time being.

Regarding your problem, you have the following options:

1. Enable forced login to comment. Comments from the currently logged-in user will be displayed to the user even if they are in review status. This can avoid the problem of disappearing after refreshing.
2. Fork the official client by yourself and modify the interaction

[Moemu]

这样的机制会引来小糖人叫骂：Moemu/Moemu/issues/4 以为博客搞控评

（我关闭了issue区：你可以在这里查看补档）

---

Such a mechanism will attract little sugar people to yell: Moemu/Moemu/issues/4 thinking that blogs are controlling comments

[SkymontVibe]

@Moemu 跑到别的仓库下面发spam也不知道是谁更唐😆

---

@Moemu went to another warehouse to send spam and I don’t know who is more stupid😆

[Moemu]

@Moemu 跑到别的仓库下面发spam也不知道是谁更唐😆

@Moemu went to another warehouse to send spam and I don’t know who is more stupid😆

机制有问题找来你不满还不给帮你说了是吧🤣🤣🤣

所以这是为什么我不喜欢评论审核而非要打开它的原因 @lizheming ，不打开怕被炸评论，打开了又被人骂，真服气。

[Moemu]

现在这个交互主要是前台插入的，用这个交互来表示评论发布成功。你说的这种交互也是可以的，但盲目的选择了你的这种交互，可能会导致习惯了之前的交互的同学又有疑惑。所以官方客户端可能需要等更多类似的反馈出来之后再考虑处理，暂时还不会去修改这个交互。

针对你的问题，你有以下几个方案：

1. 开启强制登录评论。当前登录的用户的评论，即使是在审核状态，也是会给用户展示的。这样可以规避刷新一下就没有了的问题。
2. 自行 fork 官方客户端，修改这块的交互

Now this interaction is mainly inserted in the front desk, and this interaction is used to indicate that the comment has been published successfully. The kind of interaction you mentioned is also possible, but blindly choosing your kind of interaction may cause confusion among students who are used to previous interactions. Therefore, the official client may need to wait for more similar feedback before considering processing it, and will not modify this interaction for the time being.

Regarding your problem, you have the following options:

1. Enable forced login to comment. Comments from the currently logged-in user will be displayed to the user even if they are in review status. This can avoid the problem of disappearing after refreshing.
2. Fork the official client by yourself and modify the interaction

在上述的情况下我建议是在输入框加入提示内容： 审核过程中该评论不可见。

但如果不去使用第一种方法，在匿名情况下刷新浏览器还要想办法显示未审核评论的话就有点麻烦了。