Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

CoBlocks conflict with Gutenberg 16.1+ - Copied rich text pastes in editor without line breaks #79381

Closed
mxhassani opened this issue Jul 12, 2023 · 36 comments
Labels
[Closed] Resolved Issue is resolved. Use for issues that can be closed but did not have an explicit fix with a PR. Customer Report Issues or PRs that were reported via Happiness. Previously known as "Happiness Request". [Feature] CoBlocks The integration of GoDaddy's CoBlocks plugin on WordPress.com Atomic sites. [Interaction #] > 10 (Automated) interaction count label for better visibility. Please don't add these manualliy. [Platform] Atomic [Pri] Normal [Status] 3rd Party Fix Needed A fix from a 3rd party is required to resolve this issue. [Type] Bug User Report This issue was created following a WordPress customer report User Waiting This issue has many user reports. Following here https://github.com/Automattic/wp-calypso/projects/1

Comments

@mxhassani
Copy link

mxhassani commented Jul 12, 2023

Update - This is a plugin conflict between Gutenberg 16.1+ and CoBlocks (any version). A site with both plugins active active pastes copied content without the line breaks.

Quick summary

image

Steps to reproduce

  1. Activate Tortuga or Edin theme on an AT WordPress.com site
  2. Create a new post or page
  3. Open a text editor on your computer
  4. Add text with line jumps and paragraphs
  5. Try and copy that to a paragraph block.

What you expected to happen

The text to be copied and line jumps and paragraphs to be maintained

What actually happened

Text copied without formatting

Browser

No response

Context

6528776-zd-woothemes

User Report Details

  • Atomic site with plugins added
  • Site Created: 2018
  • Theme: Tortuga (retired)
  • Specific formatting lost: paragraphs and line jumps
  • Copying from: Notepad
  • User shared original file? - YES
  • Timeline comments: "This is happening in some recent days, previously it was working well"

Platform (Simple, Atomic, or both?)

Atomic

Other notes

No response

Reproducibility

Consistent

Severity

Some (< 50%)

Available workarounds?

Yes, easy to implement

Workaround details

Create a code block, copy the text to it, then transform the block into a paragraph block.

@mxhassani mxhassani added [Type] Bug User Report This issue was created following a WordPress customer report Needs triage Ticket needs to be triaged [Feature Group] Appearance & Themes Features related to the appearance of sites. labels Jul 12, 2023
@mxhassani mxhassani changed the title Tortuga, Edin - Copying rich text formatting not carrying over to editor Tortuga, Edin, Twenty Sixteen - Copying rich text formatting not carrying over to editor Jul 13, 2023
@mxhassani
Copy link
Author

mxhassani commented Jul 13, 2023

Another case 6516370-zd-woothemes


User Report Details

  • Atomic site with plugins added
  • Site Created: 2016
  • Theme: Twenty Sixteen, Twenty Twenty-One
  • Specific formatting lost: all paragraphs pasting into one paragraph block, and the bold formatting was gone.
  • Copying from: Microsoft Word
  • User shared original file? - YES
  • Timeline comments: Problem began on July 09 (day they reported it)

@github-actions
Copy link

github-actions bot commented Jul 13, 2023

Support References

This comment is automatically generated. Please do not edit it.

  • 6528776-zen
  • 6516370-zen
  • 6519917-zen
  • 6516847-zen
  • 6526042-zen
  • 6541967-zen
  • 6558416-zen
  • 6588251-zen
  • 6636391-zen
  • 6624661-zen
  • 6543423-zen
  • 6638964-zen
  • 6680727-zen
  • 6680889-zen
  • 6661738-zen
  • 6698724-zen

@cuemarie

This comment was marked as duplicate.

@cuemarie cuemarie transferred this issue from Automattic/themes Jul 13, 2023
@cuemarie cuemarie added [Pri] Normal and removed [Pri] TBD [Feature Group] Appearance & Themes Features related to the appearance of sites. labels Jul 13, 2023
@cuemarie
Copy link

cuemarie commented Jul 13, 2023

Also had a user report new problems with copying/pasting from MS Word here: 6519917-zd-woothemes

Unclear if this is the same issue, but the user shared that for 3 years they've used the same workflow, and starting around July 7, they can no longer paste content as they had. (Gutenberg updated from 16.0.0 -> 16.1.2 on their site on July 7)

Workaround

This user found pasting into the Classic editor, then converting to blocks, worked as a workaround.


User Report Details

  • Atomic site with plugins added
  • Site Created: 2019
  • Theme: Twenty Twenty
  • Specific formatting lost: "now it comes up messy"
  • Copying from: Microsoft Word
  • User shared original file? - NO
  • Timeline comments: Reported July 10, said Friday July 7 was last time they pasted content successfully

@cuemarie

This comment was marked as outdated.

@danielbachhuber
Copy link
Contributor

danielbachhuber commented Jul 13, 2023

6516847-zd-woothemes is another report of a copy/paste issue. They're using the Gambit theme. I asked for browser, operating system, and a screencast if possible.


User Report Details

  • Atomic site with plugins added
  • Site Created: 2009
  • Theme: Gambit
  • Specific formatting lost: "Separate paragraphs are pasted into a single block"
  • Copying from: unknown
  • User shared original file? - NO
  • Timeline comments: "This worked for me until a few days ago." reported on July 09

@mxhassani
Copy link
Author

@mxhassani Are you still able to replicate on your test AT site? Can you let me know the version of Gutenberg that site is using, if so? Thank you!

@cuemarie Yes. Version 16.2.1 - Theme Edin

@renata-franco
Copy link

I landed on one of the tickets here and did some testing on an AT site to replicate it with 2021 theme. On one older site, I was able to replicate it, but on a newer site, with less plugins, I couldn't replicated it. I thought it was a plugin issue, so I tried installing the same plugins that the user has and still could not replicate it. I am not sure why in the first site had the issue but the second one did not.

@Robertght
Copy link

For 6516847-zen, here's a video recording:

ScreenRecorderProject1.mp4

@Robertght
Copy link

Robertght commented Jul 17, 2023

6526042-zen


User Report Details

  • Atomic site with plugins added
  • Site Created: 2014
  • Theme: GeneratePress (3rd party)
  • Specific formatting lost: line breaks
  • Copying from: Google Docs file (seems to be a converted .docx file)
  • User shared original file? - YES
  • Timeline comments: seems to report the issue began July 8 ("All the posts I did on saturday. I had to be pressing enter" - on July 11)

@renata-franco
Copy link

renata-franco commented Jul 17, 2023

New one: 6545142-messaging. Theme is Canard. Told them to use Classic Editor.
User wants to know once this is fixed.


User Report Details

  • Atomic site with plugins added
  • Site created: 2016
  • Theme: Canard
  • Specific formatting lost: "When we paste from word or rich text we lose the paragraphs."
  • Copying from: Word
  • User shared original file? - YES/NO
  • Timeline comments: Reported July 17: "for the last week or so"

@cuemarie cuemarie changed the title Tortuga, Edin, Twenty Sixteen - Copying rich text formatting not carrying over to editor Classic Themes - Copying rich text formatting not carrying over to editor Jul 17, 2023
@cuemarie cuemarie changed the title Classic Themes - Copying rich text formatting not carrying over to editor Classic Themes - Copying rich text formatting not carrying over to editor on some AT sites Jul 17, 2023
@cuemarie
Copy link

cuemarie commented Jul 17, 2023

Thanks for the details folks have shared so far. I've goneg back through to note specifics of each user case to try to help spot patterns.

Future HEs who report - please include these details in your report:

---

***User Report Details***
- Atomic site with plugins added
- **Site created:** 
- **Theme:** 
- **Specific formatting lost:** 
- **Copying from:** 
- **User shared original file?** - YES/NO
- **Timeline comments:**

So far, the pattern I'm seeing is that AT sites that are older than 4 years with Classic Themes are losing their paragraphs/line breaks when copying rich text over as of around July 7. Will see if I can dial that in any further with repro testing.

@cuemarie cuemarie changed the title Classic Themes - Copying rich text formatting not carrying over to editor on some AT sites Copied rich text pastes in editor without line breaks on some AT sites with Classic Themes Jul 17, 2023
@cuemarie cuemarie removed [Status] Needs Author Reply Needs triage Ticket needs to be triaged labels Jul 17, 2023
@inaikem
Copy link
Contributor

inaikem commented Jul 18, 2023

Noting this related user interaction on the 3PD Classic theme Artpop by designlabthemes

6541967-zd-woothemes


  • Atomic site with plugins
  • Site Created: March 2020
  • Theme: Artpop by designlabthemes
  • Specific formatting lost: "Return carriages are being lost when pasting content in the to WordPress block editor."
  • Copying from: n/a
  • User shared original file?* - NO
  • Timeline comments: Just that "This feature use to work"

@cuemarie
Copy link

Reported in CoBlocks repo: godaddy-wordpress/coblocks#2539

@cuemarie cuemarie added the [Feature] CoBlocks The integration of GoDaddy's CoBlocks plugin on WordPress.com Atomic sites. label Jul 20, 2023
@cuemarie cuemarie changed the title Copied rich text pastes in editor without line breaks on older AT sites with Classic Themes CoBlocks conflict with Gutenberg 16.1+ - Copied rich text pastes in editor without line breaks Jul 20, 2023
@danielbachhuber danielbachhuber removed their assignment Jul 20, 2023
@csabarakasz
Copy link

6516847-zd-woothemes

Sharing the workaround to disable CoBlocks.

@rinazrina
Copy link

Another one: 6588251-zd-woothemes

Sharing the workaround to disable CoBlocks.

@csabarakasz
Copy link

6636391-zd-a8c

Sharing the workaround to disable CoBlocks.

@zdenys
Copy link
Contributor

zdenys commented Aug 13, 2023

6624661-zd-a8c Sharing the workaround to disable CoBlocks.

@github-actions github-actions bot added the Customer Report Issues or PRs that were reported via Happiness. Previously known as "Happiness Request". label Aug 13, 2023
@cuemarie
Copy link

I've noted on the CoBlocks report that we continue to see reports of this issue come in. godaddy-wordpress/coblocks#2539 (comment)

@essleeung
Copy link

Another report here- 6543423-zd-a8c. Disabled Coblocks for now.

@github-actions github-actions bot added the [Interaction #] > 10 (Automated) interaction count label for better visibility. Please don't add these manualliy. label Aug 16, 2023
@janmckell
Copy link

Another report here - 6638964-zd-a8c Disabled Coblocks and this resolved it.

@Robertght
Copy link

6680727-zen / 6680889-zen in chat the user confirmed that rolling back to GB 15.2 worked ok for them. They'd like to be notified when this is fixed.

@cuemarie cuemarie added the User Waiting This issue has many user reports. Following here https://github.com/Automattic/wp-calypso/projects/1 label Aug 17, 2023
@cuemarie
Copy link

cuemarie commented Aug 17, 2023

@Robertght I've added this to our 'User Waiting' board in case this ever gets fixed by CoBlocks, but I would not give users any expectation of hearing from us soon on that! We're really just waiting to see if CoBlocks ever addresses it, but as we've deprecated CoBlocks' integration with WordPress.com sites (p9oQ9f-1yg-p2), we likely won't do more than that.

CoBlocks issue, for reference: godaddy-wordpress/coblocks#2539

@zdenys
Copy link
Contributor

zdenys commented Aug 20, 2023

6661738-zd-a8c Sharing the workaround to disable CoBlocks.

@Mfarroq1
Copy link

6698724-zd-a8c Sharing the workaround to disable CoBlocks.

@AnthonyLedesma
Copy link

Hi Folks. This issue from CoBlocks is resolved with the release of 3.1.3.
Related PR: godaddy-wordpress/coblocks#2563

@cuemarie
Copy link

📌 ACTIONS

@cuemarie cuemarie added [Closed] Resolved Issue is resolved. Use for issues that can be closed but did not have an explicit fix with a PR. [Status] 3rd Party Fix Needed A fix from a 3rd party is required to resolve this issue. and removed [Status] Blocked / Hold labels Aug 30, 2023
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
[Closed] Resolved Issue is resolved. Use for issues that can be closed but did not have an explicit fix with a PR. Customer Report Issues or PRs that were reported via Happiness. Previously known as "Happiness Request". [Feature] CoBlocks The integration of GoDaddy's CoBlocks plugin on WordPress.com Atomic sites. [Interaction #] > 10 (Automated) interaction count label for better visibility. Please don't add these manualliy. [Platform] Atomic [Pri] Normal [Status] 3rd Party Fix Needed A fix from a 3rd party is required to resolve this issue. [Type] Bug User Report This issue was created following a WordPress customer report User Waiting This issue has many user reports. Following here https://github.com/Automattic/wp-calypso/projects/1
Projects
Development

No branches or pull requests