Skip to content
New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Fix missing LoAF attribution when entries are dispatched before event entries #487

Merged
merged 3 commits into from
Jun 6, 2024

Conversation

brendankenny
Copy link
Member

fixes #485

As described there, I added an extra condition to keep any LoAFs around that are after any existing known interactions, in case those interactions then come in later.

I then realized that would leave the LoAF collection unbounded, since a page can have a bunch of slow animation frames without the user interacting. I added a MAX_UNPAIRED_LOAFS of 20, so it will only keep the 20 most recent LoAFs after any known user interaction events. The number isn't hugely important, that just allows a one second delay in event-timing reporting even if the page somehow has filled the time with the shortest (50ms) long animation frames possible. LoAF entries are fairly light weight, so that's not so bad.

As I was implementing this, however, I realized that even without this change the pendingLoAFs array can grow without bound on a page with e.g. animations and a busy main thread, since LoAFs are appended as they come in but clean up is only scheduled by user interactions. Seems like we should fix? @philipwalton @tunetheweb

My only idea right now is to split the event timing and LoAF cleanups into two separate functions, and run each as their respective entries come in, since that's the only time each list of entries grows.

@brendankenny
Copy link
Member Author

brendankenny commented May 23, 2024

Oh, also I could not get a test for this working reliably. Inherently flaky and subject to future Chrome scheduler changes anyways. I verified the issue repro no longer fails, but looking for other ideas on this. Time to bust out some unit tests? Override PerformanceObserver in an e2e test?

@tunetheweb
Copy link
Member

As I was implementing this, however, I realized that even without this change the pendingLoAFs array can grow without bound on a page with e.g. animations and a busy main thread, since LoAFs are appended as they come in but clean up is only scheduled by user interactions. Seems like we should fix? @philipwalton @tunetheweb

Maybe we should do this clean up in handleLoAFEntries then (behind a whenIdle call)?
At the moment we queue a clean up interactions when new interactions come in, so we should also queue LoAFs clean ups when they come in.

@philipwalton philipwalton self-requested a review June 6, 2024 05:11
Copy link
Member

@philipwalton philipwalton left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

Thanks for taking a look at this @brendankenny, and for the detailed repro. It was very helpful for testing this!

I took Barry's suggestion and made a few other minor tweaks to the code, but other than that LGTM.

Copy link
Member

@tunetheweb tunetheweb left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

LGTM but some nits on comments.

src/attribution/onINP.ts Outdated Show resolved Hide resolved
src/attribution/onINP.ts Show resolved Hide resolved
@philipwalton
Copy link
Member

Updated, and also moved the whenIdle() call to within the main onINP() function (as mentioned here) to ensure that attribution is always processed synchronously with the INP dispatch.

@philipwalton philipwalton merged commit d58dbab into main Jun 6, 2024
8 checks passed
@philipwalton philipwalton deleted the ooo-loafs branch June 6, 2024 22:32
@philipwalton philipwalton changed the title INP attribution: allow for LoAFs observed before interaction events Fix missing LoAF attribution when entries are dispatched before event entries Jun 6, 2024
zemnmez-renovate-bot added a commit to zemn-me/monorepo that referenced this pull request Oct 5, 2024
##### [`v4.2.3](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v423-2024-08-06)

-   Fix missing LoAF entries in INP attribution ([#512](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#512))
##### [`v4.2.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v422-2024-07-17)

-   Fix interaction count after bfcache restore ([#505](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#505))
##### [`v4.2.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v421-2024-06-30)

-   Fix compatibility issues with TypeScript v5.5 ([#497](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#497))
##### [`v4.2.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v420-2024-06-20)

-   Refactor INP attribution code to fix errors on Windows 10 ([#495](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#495))
##### [`v4.1.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v411-2024-06-10)

-   Fix pending LoAF cleanup logic ([#493](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#493))
##### [`v4.1.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v410-2024-06-06)

-   Move the support check to the top of the onINP() function ([#490](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#490))
-   Fix missing LoAF attribution when entries are dispatched before event entries ([#487](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#487))
##### [`v4.0.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v401-2024-05-21)

-   Add the `ReportCallback` type back but deprecate it ([#483](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#483))
##### [`v4.0.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v400-2024-05-13)

-   **\[BREAKING]** Update types to support more generic usage ([#471](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#471))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Split `waitingDuration` to make it easier to understand redirect delays ([#458](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#458))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Rename `TTFBAttribution` fields from `*Time` to `*Duration` ([#453](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#453))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Rename `resourceLoadTime` to `resourceLoadDuration` in LCP attribution ([#450](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#450))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Add INP breakdown timings and LoAF attribution ([#442](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#442))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Deprecate `onFID()` and remove previously deprecated APIs ([#435](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#435))
-   Expose the target element in INP attribution ([#479](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#479))
-   Save INP target after interactions to reduce null values when removed from the DOM ([#477](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#477))
-   Cap TTFB in attribution ([#440](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#440))
-   Fix `reportAllChanges` behavior for LCP when library is loaded late ([#468](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#468))
##### [`v3.5.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v352-2024-01-25)

-   Pick the first non-null `target` for INP attribution ([#421](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#421))
##### [`v3.5.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v351-2023-12-27)

-   Add extra guard for `PerformanceEventTiming` not existing ([#403](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#403))
##### [`v3.5.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v350-2023-09-28)

-   Run `onLCP` callback in separate task ([#386](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#386))
-   Fix INP durationThreshold bug when set to 0 ([#372](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#372))
-   Prevent FID entries being emitted as INP for non-supporting browsers ([#368](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#368))
##### [`v3.4.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v340-2023-07-11)

-   Make `bindReporter` generic over metric type ([#359](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#359))
-   Update INP status in README ([#362](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#362))
-   Fix Metric types for better TypeScript support ([#356](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#356))
-   Fix selector for SVGs for attribution build ([#354](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#354))
##### [`v3.3.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v332-2023-05-29)

-   Fix attribution types ([#348](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#348))
-   Safe access navigation entry type ([#290](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#290))
##### [`v3.3.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v331-2023-04-04)

-   Export metric rating thresholds in attribution build as well.
##### [`v3.3.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v330-2023-03-09)

-   Export metric rating thresholds, add explicit `MetricRatingThresholds` type ([#323](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#323))
-   Trim classname selector ([#328](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#328))
-   Add link to CrUX versus RUM blog post ([#327](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#327))
-   Prevent LCP being reported for hidden prerendered pages ([#326](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#326))
-   Add Server Timing information to docs ([#324](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#324))
-   Fix link in `onINP()` thresholds comment ([#318](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#318))
-   Update web.dev link for `onINP()` ([#307](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#307))
-   Add a note about when to load the library ([#305](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#305))
##### [`v3.1.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v311-2023-01-10)

-   Defer CLS logic until after `onFCP()` callback ([#297](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#297))
##### [`v3.1.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v310-2022-11-15)

-   Add support for `'restore'` as a `navigationType` ([#284](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#284))
-   Report initial CLS value when `reportAllChanges` is true ([#283](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#283))
-   Defer all observers until after activation ([#282](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#282))
-   Ignore TTFB for loads where responseStart is zero ([#281](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#281))
-   Defer execution of observer callbacks ([#278](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#278))
##### [`v3.0.4](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v304-2022-10-18)

-   Clamp LCP and FCP to 0 for prerendered pages ([#270](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#270))
##### [`v3.0.3](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v303-2022-10-04)

-   Ensure `attribution` object is always present in attribution build ([#265](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#265))
##### [`v3.0.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v302-2022-09-14)

-   Set an explicit unpkg dist file ([#261](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#261))
##### [`v3.0.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v301-2022-08-31)

-   Use the cjs extension for all UMD builds ([#257](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#257))
##### [`v3.0.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v300-2022-08-24)

-   **\[BREAKING]** Add a config object param to all metric functions ([#225](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#225))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Report TTFB after a bfcache restore ([#220](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#220))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Only include last LCP entry in metric entries ([#218](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#218))
-   Update the metric ID prefix for v3 ([#251](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#251))
-   Move the Navigation Timing API polyfill to the base+polyfill build ([#248](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#248))
-   Add a metric rating property ([#246](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#246))
-   Add deprecation notices for base+polyfill builds ([#242](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#242))
-   Add a new attribution build for debugging issues in the field ([#237](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#237), [#244](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#244))
-   Add support for prerendered pages ([#233](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#233))
-   Rename the `ReportHandler` type to `ReportCallback`, with alias for back-compat ([#225](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#225), [#227](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#227))
-   Add support for the new INP metric ([#221](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#221), [#232](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#232))
-   Rename `getXXX()` functions to `onXXX()` ([#222](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#222))
-   Add a `navigationType` property to the Metric object ([#219](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#219))
github-merge-queue bot pushed a commit to zemn-me/monorepo that referenced this pull request Oct 5, 2024
##### [`v4.2.3](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v423-2024-08-06)

-   Fix missing LoAF entries in INP attribution ([#512](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#512))
##### [`v4.2.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v422-2024-07-17)

-   Fix interaction count after bfcache restore ([#505](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#505))
##### [`v4.2.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v421-2024-06-30)

-   Fix compatibility issues with TypeScript v5.5 ([#497](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#497))
##### [`v4.2.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v420-2024-06-20)

-   Refactor INP attribution code to fix errors on Windows 10 ([#495](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#495))
##### [`v4.1.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v411-2024-06-10)

-   Fix pending LoAF cleanup logic ([#493](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#493))
##### [`v4.1.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v410-2024-06-06)

-   Move the support check to the top of the onINP() function ([#490](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#490))
-   Fix missing LoAF attribution when entries are dispatched before event entries ([#487](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#487))
##### [`v4.0.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v401-2024-05-21)

-   Add the `ReportCallback` type back but deprecate it ([#483](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#483))
##### [`v4.0.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v400-2024-05-13)

-   **\[BREAKING]** Update types to support more generic usage ([#471](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#471))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Split `waitingDuration` to make it easier to understand redirect delays ([#458](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#458))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Rename `TTFBAttribution` fields from `*Time` to `*Duration` ([#453](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#453))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Rename `resourceLoadTime` to `resourceLoadDuration` in LCP attribution ([#450](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#450))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Add INP breakdown timings and LoAF attribution ([#442](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#442))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Deprecate `onFID()` and remove previously deprecated APIs ([#435](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#435))
-   Expose the target element in INP attribution ([#479](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#479))
-   Save INP target after interactions to reduce null values when removed from the DOM ([#477](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#477))
-   Cap TTFB in attribution ([#440](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#440))
-   Fix `reportAllChanges` behavior for LCP when library is loaded late ([#468](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#468))
##### [`v3.5.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v352-2024-01-25)

-   Pick the first non-null `target` for INP attribution ([#421](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#421))
##### [`v3.5.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v351-2023-12-27)

-   Add extra guard for `PerformanceEventTiming` not existing ([#403](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#403))
##### [`v3.5.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v350-2023-09-28)

-   Run `onLCP` callback in separate task ([#386](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#386))
-   Fix INP durationThreshold bug when set to 0 ([#372](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#372))
-   Prevent FID entries being emitted as INP for non-supporting browsers ([#368](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#368))
##### [`v3.4.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v340-2023-07-11)

-   Make `bindReporter` generic over metric type ([#359](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#359))
-   Update INP status in README ([#362](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#362))
-   Fix Metric types for better TypeScript support ([#356](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#356))
-   Fix selector for SVGs for attribution build ([#354](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#354))
##### [`v3.3.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v332-2023-05-29)

-   Fix attribution types ([#348](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#348))
-   Safe access navigation entry type ([#290](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#290))
##### [`v3.3.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v331-2023-04-04)

-   Export metric rating thresholds in attribution build as well.
##### [`v3.3.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v330-2023-03-09)

-   Export metric rating thresholds, add explicit `MetricRatingThresholds` type ([#323](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#323))
-   Trim classname selector ([#328](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#328))
-   Add link to CrUX versus RUM blog post ([#327](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#327))
-   Prevent LCP being reported for hidden prerendered pages ([#326](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#326))
-   Add Server Timing information to docs ([#324](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#324))
-   Fix link in `onINP()` thresholds comment ([#318](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#318))
-   Update web.dev link for `onINP()` ([#307](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#307))
-   Add a note about when to load the library ([#305](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#305))
##### [`v3.1.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v311-2023-01-10)

-   Defer CLS logic until after `onFCP()` callback ([#297](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#297))
##### [`v3.1.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v310-2022-11-15)

-   Add support for `'restore'` as a `navigationType` ([#284](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#284))
-   Report initial CLS value when `reportAllChanges` is true ([#283](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#283))
-   Defer all observers until after activation ([#282](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#282))
-   Ignore TTFB for loads where responseStart is zero ([#281](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#281))
-   Defer execution of observer callbacks ([#278](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#278))
##### [`v3.0.4](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v304-2022-10-18)

-   Clamp LCP and FCP to 0 for prerendered pages ([#270](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#270))
##### [`v3.0.3](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v303-2022-10-04)

-   Ensure `attribution` object is always present in attribution build ([#265](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#265))
##### [`v3.0.2](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v302-2022-09-14)

-   Set an explicit unpkg dist file ([#261](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#261))
##### [`v3.0.1](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v301-2022-08-31)

-   Use the cjs extension for all UMD builds ([#257](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#257))
##### [`v3.0.0](https://github.com/GoogleChrome/web-vitals/blob/HEAD/CHANGELOG.md#v300-2022-08-24)

-   **\[BREAKING]** Add a config object param to all metric functions ([#225](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#225))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Report TTFB after a bfcache restore ([#220](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#220))
-   **\[BREAKING]** Only include last LCP entry in metric entries ([#218](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#218))
-   Update the metric ID prefix for v3 ([#251](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#251))
-   Move the Navigation Timing API polyfill to the base+polyfill build ([#248](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#248))
-   Add a metric rating property ([#246](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#246))
-   Add deprecation notices for base+polyfill builds ([#242](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#242))
-   Add a new attribution build for debugging issues in the field ([#237](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#237), [#244](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#244))
-   Add support for prerendered pages ([#233](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#233))
-   Rename the `ReportHandler` type to `ReportCallback`, with alias for back-compat ([#225](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#225), [#227](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#227))
-   Add support for the new INP metric ([#221](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#221), [#232](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#232))
-   Rename `getXXX()` functions to `onXXX()` ([#222](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#222))
-   Add a `navigationType` property to the Metric object ([#219](GoogleChrome/web-vitals#219))
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment
Labels
None yet
Projects
None yet
Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

LoAF missed for some INP events
3 participants