Added string formatting options to ToQuantity

[dealdiane]

No description provided.

[dealdiane]

readme probably needs updating as well?

[MehdiK]

I like it. Good work :)

Yes, we need to include this in the readme or no one's ever going to know about it.

[dealdiane]

Done. Please proofread though.

[MehdiK]

Thanks for adding the readme bit.

There are three failing tests. Also your fork is quite a few commits behind the upstream. Please fix the tests and rebase your work. Thanks.

[MehdiK]

This is pretty cool. Thanks for the great addition.

[dealdiane]

Is it the tests I have added that are failing?

[MehdiK]

Yes.

Test 'Humanizer.Tests.ToQuantityTests.ToQuantityWordsWithCustomCultureFormatting(word: "case", quantity: 1234567, format: "N2", cultureCode: "de-CH", expected: "1 234 567,00 cases")' failed:
Assert.Equal() Failure
Position: First difference is at position 1
Expected: 1 234 567,00 cases
Actual: 1'234'567.00 cases
ToQuantityTests.cs(116,0): at Humanizer.Tests.ToQuantityTests.ToQuantityWordsWithCustomCultureFormatting(String word, Int32 quantity, String format, String cultureCode, String expected)

Test 'Humanizer.Tests.ToQuantityTests.ToQuantityWordsWithCustomCultureFormatting(word: "case", quantity: 1234567, format: "N0", cultureCode: "de-CH", expected: "1 234 567 cases")' failed:
Assert.Equal() Failure
Position: First difference is at position 1
Expected: 1 234 567 cases
Actual: 1'234'567 cases
ToQuantityTests.cs(116,0): at Humanizer.Tests.ToQuantityTests.ToQuantityWordsWithCustomCultureFormatting(String word, Int32 quantity, String format, String cultureCode, String expected)

Test 'Humanizer.Tests.ApiApprover.PublicApiApprovalTest.approve_public_api' failed: ApprovalTests.Core.Exceptions.ApprovalMismatchException : Failed Approval: Received file c:_mine\Code\Humanizer\src\Humanizer.Tests\ApiApprover\PublicApiApprovalTest.approve_public_api.received.txt does not match approved file c:_mine\Code\Humanizer\src\Humanizer.Tests\ApiApprover\PublicApiApprovalTest.approve_public_api.approved.txt.

[dealdiane]

Just did a rebase.
That is weird. All my tests are green except for that one I just fixed now.

Can you by any chance run this piece of code on your machine and paste your output here?

var number = 1234567;
number.ToString("N0", new CultureInfo("en-US")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));
number.ToString("N2", new CultureInfo("en-US")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));
number.ToString("N0", new CultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));
number.ToString("N2", new CultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));

49:1-44:,-50:2-51:3-52:4-44:,-53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-44:,-50:2-51:3-52:4-44:,-53:5-54:6-55:7-46:.-48:0-48:0-
49:1-160: -50:2-51:3-52:4-160: -53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-160: -50:2-51:3-52:4-160: -53:5-54:6-55:7-44:,-48:0-48:0-

[MehdiK]

Sure. Here it is:

49:1-44:,-50:2-51:3-52:4-44:,-53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-44:,-50:2-51:3-52:4-44:,-53:5-54:6-55:7-46:.-48:0-48:0-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-46:.-48:0-48:0-

These quotation marks are strange!

[dealdiane]

Yeah, seems strange that the same culture is giving different results. May I know what version of .NET you're running the tests on and on what platform?

I've made a slight change in the same code above. Was wondering if you can run it again?

var number = 1234567;
number.ToString("N0", new CultureInfo("de-CH", true)).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));
number.ToString("N2", new CultureInfo("de-CH", false)).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));
number.ToString("N0", CultureInfo.GetCultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));
number.ToString("N2", CultureInfo.GetCultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));

[MehdiK]

49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-46:.-48:0-48:0-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-46:.-48:0-48:0-

On Wed, Apr 16, 2014 at 1:04 PM, opiants notifications@github.com wrote:

Yeah, seems strange that the same culture is giving different results. May
I know what version of .NET you're running the tests on and on what
platform?

I've made a slight change in the same code above. Was wondering if you can
run it again?

var number = 1234567;number.ToString("N0", new CultureInfo("de-CH", true)).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));number.ToString("N2", new CultureInfo("de-CH", false)).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));number.ToString("N0", CultureInfo.GetCultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));number.ToString("N2", CultureInfo.GetCultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com//pull/220#issuecomment-40575402
.

[MehdiK]

I created the test in the Humanizer test project.

On Wed, Apr 16, 2014 at 1:06 PM, Mehdi Khalili me@mehdi-khalili.com wrote:

49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-46:.-48:0-48:0-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-
49:1-39:'-50:2-51:3-52:4-39:'-53:5-54:6-55:7-46:.-48:0-48:0-

On Wed, Apr 16, 2014 at 1:04 PM, opiants notifications@github.com wrote:

Yeah, seems strange that the same culture is giving different results.
May I know what version of .NET you're running the tests on and on what
platform?

I've made a slight change in the same code above. Was wondering if you
can run it again?

var number = 1234567;number.ToString("N0", new CultureInfo("de-CH", true)).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));number.ToString("N2", new CultureInfo("de-CH", false)).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));number.ToString("N0", CultureInfo.GetCultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));number.ToString("N2", CultureInfo.GetCultureInfo("de-CH")).ToList().ForEach(x => Console.Write((int)x + ":" + x + "-"));

Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHubhttps://github.com//pull/220#issuecomment-40575402
.

[dealdiane]

Strangely enough, running the tests on <= 3.5 will return the same format you are getting but on > 4.0 it returns what I'm getting. I don't think the framework version is the problem though cos the project's target framework is 4.0 and should be the same for everyone? But surely it has something to do with the framework but just can't figure out what and why.

What do you suggest we do going forward?

[dealdiane]

They've updated the number formats on newer OSes and frameworks and it seems that they won't bother updating the number formats to make it more consistent.

https://connect.microsoft.com/VisualStudio/feedback/details/772498/inconsistent-formatting-behavior-of-double-tostring-in-net-3-5-vs-4-x
http://social.msdn.microsoft.com/Forums/vstudio/en-US/3ac50c1a-4f0b-450f-82f2-686a89766391/suddenly-no-more-group-seperator-for-culture-ptpt-in-clr-4-win8?forum=netfxbcl

I'll update the tests so it'll use a more consistent culture code and stop it from failing.

[MehdiK]

Sorry I couldn't this yesterday. Had a crazy day! That was an interesting issue & good find.

Thanks for the great work. Merged now.

[MehdiK]

Thanks for the contribution. This is now available on NuGet as v1.23.1.