Export to MS Office 2007 XML file puts DOI in the StandardNumber tag

[exch-0930]

• JabRef version (available in the About box): 2.11b4
• Operating system and version: Windows 7, Word 2013
• Steps to reproduce:
  1. ...File, Export to MS Office 2007 format
  2. ...Open XML with Notepad and you can see the tagging
  3. ...In Word, References tab, Manage Source, Browse, chose file that was exported, Edit, you will see DOI in the standard number field
  4. If applicable, excerpt of the bibliography file, screenshot, and excerpt of log (available in the error console)

[matthiasgeiger]

Yes.
There is no "DOI" tag or anything else like this. Therefore, the former developers seems to have interpreted the "StandardNumber" tag as a "standardized number" and not as a "number of a standard" and therefore put the DOI/ISBN in there...

What do you propose to change?

[exch-0930]

Just change the XML export tagging from <b:StandardNumber> to <b:DOI>. Right now, we do a search and replace on the exported XML file and it import it into Word with the DOI number in the DOI box in Word 2013.
Thanks for Jabref. It has some very nice features.

------ Original Message ------

Received: 04:11 AM EDT, 03/16/2016

From: Matthias Geiger notifications@github.com

To: JabRef/jabref jabref@noreply.github.com
Cc: exch-0930 exch-0930@usa.net

Subject: Re: [jabref] Export to MS Office 2007 XML file puts DOI in the StandardNumber tag (#973)

Yes.

There is no "DOI" tag or anything else like this. Therefore, the former developers seems to have interpreted the "StandardNumber" tag as a "standardized number" and not as a "number of a standard" and therefore put the DOI/ISBN in there...

What do you propose to change?

—
You are receiving this because you authored the thread.
Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub

[simonharrer]

What about storing the DOI in the <b:DOI> tag in addition to using the <b:StandardNumber>? When looking at the interface in word 2010, there is onyl a standard number field, no DOI field. Because of this, the mapping was done.

http://mahbub.wordpress.com/2007/03/24/details-of-microsoft-office-2007-bibliographic-format-compared-to-bibtex/ is a comparison of bibtex and word.

JabRef also stores ISBN or other numbers in the standard number field, depending on their availability, I think. See MSBibDatabase and MSBibEntry.

[matthiasgeiger]

http://www.ecma-international.org/publications/standards/Ecma-376.htm - this is the standard MS is using. In ECMA-376 4th edition Part 4 you can find the XML schema (shared-bibliography.xsd) for the bibliography definition. And there is nothing like "ISBN" or "DOI" defined.

[simonharrer]

@exch-0930 could you provide a screenshot of word which has the doi box?

@matthiasgeiger may be office 2013 uses another standard?

[exch-0930]

I have attached a screenshot from Word 2013. Word 2010 also has the same fields.
To see the DOI and some other fields, you must check the box "Show All Bibliography Fields".

Thanks

[exch-0930]

I found a youtube video that shows the DOI field in Word 2010. Skip to the 2:31 minutes mark in this video:

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oDEF5aYDDEE

[matthiasgeiger]

Not available here (MS Word 2010 German edition):

[matthiasgeiger]

Additional note: Even after manually creating the <b:DOI>...</b:DOI> tag in an exported XML file, the DOI field does not show up in the dialog above.

[exch-0930]

Do you have the latest Office updates?

 

I also found the DOI in a screenshot on page 5 of this US college tutorial, so I know it is not just a me.

http://www.allegany.edu/Documents/Library/Tips%20on%20using%20Microsoft%20Word%20to%20create%20Bibliographies%20and%20Citations.pdf

Is there a way for me to create a custom export from Jabref or do I need to download the source code and change it?

 

Thanks

 

------ Original Message ------
Received: 04:33 PM EDT, 03/23/2016
From: Matthias Geiger notifications@github.com
To: JabRef/jabref jabref@noreply.github.com
Cc: exch-0930 exch-0930@usa.net
Subject: Re: [jabref] Export to MS Office 2007 XML file puts DOI in the StandardNumber tag (#973)

  Additional note: Even after manually creating the <b:DOI>...</b:DOI> tag in an exported XML file, the DOI field does not show up in the dialog above.

  —
    You are receiving this because you modified the open/close state.
    Reply to this email directly or view it on GitHub

[Siedlerchr]

Very mysterious thing. I also have the same dialog like @matthiasgeiger in Word 2010 German.
Edit// Seems to be a difference between the English and the German version:

Look at page 10:
http://www.wendelinsseiten.info/app/download/7111093485/Anleitung+Chicago-Style+Vers+2013-04-25.pdf?t=1367264061

[stefan-kolb]

So what can we do about this?

[simonharrer]

What about just exporting the doi in the doi tag additionally? I do not see any downside.

[matthiasgeiger]

Well, the resulting file would be schema invalid regarding the ECMA-376 standard... But as Word (in the English version) seems to produce such "invalid" files this should not cause much trouble.

[Siedlerchr]

I know this has been closed, but just some additional information: In the German version of Office 2013 there is now a DOI field, too.