Discrete GPU temperature is not being read [fixed in v.1.5.8.1 beta, download here]

[Rossh51]

Download version 1.5.8.1.26 beta

Previously reported in 1.58 beta but not fixed in release. When Discrete GPU checked in Preferences there is no Temp reading for 5700XT GPU. Unchecking gives all readings as in previous versions. See screen shots with and without check box active.

[kleuter]

Looks like 5700XT temperature on this iMac model should be read using the SMC sensor GPU Die. Will do that, thanks for the follow up.

[deejaykris]

Same thing on my MacBook Pro late 2013.

[kleuter]

deejaykris,
Please run the complete command in Terminal
ioreg -l > output.txt
and post here output.txt (using the browser)

[Rossh51]

output.txt

[deejaykris]

output.txt

[pfk84]

Same on MacBook Pro 16"
output.txt

[kleuter]

If possible, send a screenshot as well, please

[ikonkere]

Same on mbp10,1 (15" retina late-2012), OSX 10.14.6:

output.txt

[eggicusroundplumpius]

output.txt
Same on 16 Inch MacBook Pro with 5600M graphics - it will not read either the Intel HD 630 or AMD 5600M directly, though GPU PECI still works when the option is disabled.

[pfk84]

[kleuter]

Please try this test build and post your screenshot, thank you!

[Rossh51]

Yes, this works with EGU option on or off. Thank you for this. Great work.

There is now no ability to see individual GPU sensors however. Is it possible to have the option to toggle as we did before?

Screen shots below.

[kleuter]

Basically GPU Die sensor has now more meaningful name with GPU model.
Sensors found in previous versions must be visible again in the beta build:

Download version 1.5.8.1.25 beta

and post here your screenshots, thanks.

[Rossh51]

Better again with some GPU information. I assume the GPU reading is what was listed as the GPU Diode?

[eggicusroundplumpius]

Still no reading on the 5600M, but we now have a reading on the HD 630. I did try disabling auto-graphics switching to see if it just needed to have that GPU selected but it didn't do anything.

[kleuter]

Still no reading on the 5600M

Please post tech info as described at #407, best right after some heavy GPU task

Please also run the complete command in Terminal
ioreg -l > output.txt
and post here output.txt (using the browser)

[kleuter]

I assume the GPU reading is what was listed as the GPU Diode?

Exactly.

[lokmac]

This fixed it for my MBP Late-2013 with GeForce GT 750M.

[pfk84]

Intel UHD works now, thanks! However, it still cannot read the Radeon Pro 5500M; going to try my eGPU next week as well.

[kleuter]

All macbook pro users (16,1, 15,1) please try the update, it must display discrete GPU temperature, but please run also the Valley benchmark to make sure the temperature rises properly.

Download version 1.5.8.1.26 beta

[eggicusroundplumpius]

Okay, it seems to work but the temperature doesn’t report “accurately” - it’s always rounded to the nearest degree, which isn’t a problem and may be by design but worth nothing, I guess.

…

On 4 Oct 2020, at 20:30, Kleuter ***@***.***> wrote: All macbook pro users (16,1, 15,1) please try the update, it will display discrete GPU temperature, but please run also the Valley benchmark <https://benchmark.unigine.com/valley> to make sure the temperature rises properly. Download version 1.5.8.1.26 beta <https://crystalidea.com/downloads/macsfancontrol_beta.zip> — You are receiving this because you commented. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#400 (comment)>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ADYTE75PMCN7DOVMB6IXJJDSJDEOVANCNFSM4R3HDDAA>.

[deejaykris]

This Beta Version works for my MacBook Pro 15" Late 2013
Thanks :)

[kleuter]

@eggicusroundplumpius did you run the Valley benchmark? What was the max temp for 5600M?

[eggicusroundplumpius]

The max was something like 79°, if I remember correctly.

…

On 5 Oct 2020, at 09:39, Kleuter ***@***.***> wrote:  @eggicusroundplumpius did you run the Valley benchmark? What was the max temp for 5600M? — You are receiving this because you were mentioned. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub, or unsubscribe.

[kleuter]

Thanks

[pfk84]

Works now, great! The highest temp I'd seen was 96°C, matches what other tools are saying. Also the eGPU works just fine...

[kleuter]

Thanks! Which eGPU did you connect? Thanks.

[pfk84]

Radeon RX 580

[kleuter]

Perfect, thanks!

[kleuter]

Fixed in 1.5.8.1