Skip to content

Why do I have limited servo throw in my airplane

dingrgh edited this page Sep 15, 2019 · 13 revisions

Explanation of why you have limited throw in any stabilisation mode. ( Including Rate / Acro )

First basic PIFF controller:

  • P-gain will change your servo movement when it sees an error between wanted motion ( deg/s ) and actual motion ( deg/s )
  • I-gain will change your servo movement when it sees an error between wanted motion ( deg/s ) and actual motion ( deg/s ), however I-gain also knows the concept of time, and therefor will contuinue to increase servo movement until actual motion is the same as wanted motion.
  • FF-gain doesnt not care about actual motion, and does only move servos based on wanted motion.

Also Angle mode itself have an P-gain to level the aircraft back to level.

Also an sidenote is that I-gain is suppressed before takeoff and without throttle, EVEN with airmode enable you need to first have had some throttle to see the I-gain working, this is important to know if you want to "bench" test behavior.

Passthrough bypasses all this an moves servos directly.

In other words, the only thing that will limit passthrough servo limits and rates set up in the Servos tab.

What is stabilisation? And how do you as the pilot control the airplane in a stabilised mode?

In passthrough everything is easy, you move sticks on radio, the FC does some mixing according to which airplane/flying wing you have, and then you move the servos directly.

In stabiliation mode however you dont control the servos at ALL. Everything is controlled by actual motion, and wanted motion. When you move the sticks you are commanding motion, example 30deg/s roll.

Then the P-gain will start working, the I-gain will start working and the FF-gain will start working, if tuned properly it will hit the wanted motion.

So what does this have to do with limited servo throws?

  1. For actual testing on bench you will need to arm and apply throttle to see how much the servos actual moves in flight.

2:

An typical wing can example manage 500 deg/s, default rate values for INAV is 200deg/s.

QUIZ: You command 100% right roll, which would be 200deg/s. What would happend if it did give you full servo throw?

Yes, it would have hit 500deg/s instead and overshoot target motion.

Sum up:

You dont need full servo throw! It all depends how you want to tune your airplane.

IF you want full throw, your rate settings ( deg/s ) should match what your plane is able to do at full servo throw. Then in stabilitation mode you increase your P-gain or FF-gain untill you get full throw on servos.

Sidenote: For older firmeware, If you want to calm your airplane in passthrough mode, you will need an programmable TX. Program it so when enabling passthrough on a switch, the switch also reduce channel range and adds expo.

In modern firmware, with manual mode (which replaces passthrough), the FC imposes expo and rates.

WIKI TOPICS

Wiki Home Page

INAV Version Release Notes

7.1.0 Release Notes
7.0.0 Release Notes
6.0.0 Release Notes
5.1 Release notes
5.0.0 Release Notes
4.1.0 Release Notes
4.0.0 Release Notes
3.0.0 Release Notes
2.6.0 Release Notes
2.5.1 Release notes
2.5.0 Release Notes
2.4.0 Release Notes
2.3.0 Release Notes
2.2.1 Release Notes
2.2.0 Release Notes
2.1.0 Release Notes
2.0.0 Release Notes
1.9.1 Release notes
1.9.0 Release notes
1.8.0 Release notes
1.7.3 Release notes
Older Release Notes

QUICK START GUIDES

Getting started with iNav
Fixed Wing Guide
Howto: CC3D flight controller, minimOSD , telemetry and GPS for fixed wing
Howto: CC3D flight controller, minimOSD, GPS and LTM telemetry for fixed wing
INAV for BetaFlight users
launch mode
Multirotor guide
YouTube video guides
DevDocs Getting Started.md
DevDocs INAV_Fixed_Wing_Setup_Guide.pdf
DevDocs Safety.md

Connecting to INAV

Bluetooth setup to configure your flight controller
DevDocs Wireless Connections (BLE, TCP and UDP).md\

Flashing and Upgrading

Boards, Targets and PWM allocations
Upgrading from an older version of INAV to the current version
DevDocs Installation.md
DevDocs USB Flashing.md

Setup Tab
Live 3D Graphic & Pre-Arming Checks

Calibration Tab
Accelerometer, Compass, & Optic Flow Calibration

Alignment Tool Tab
Adjust mount angle of FC & Compass

Ports Tab
Map Devices to UART Serial Ports

Receiver Tab
Set protocol and channel mapping

Mixer

Mixer Tab
Custom mixes for exotic setups
DevDocs Mixer.md

Outputs

DevDocs ESC and servo outputs.md
DevDocs Servo.md

Modes

Modes
Navigation modes
Navigation Mode: Return to Home
DevDocs Controls.md
DevDocs INAV_Modes.pdf
DevDocs Navigation.md

Configuration

Sensor auto detect and hardware failure detection

Failsafe

Failsafe
DevDocs Failsafe.md

PID Tuning

PID Attenuation and scaling
Fixed Wing Tuning for INAV 3.0
Tune INAV PIFF controller for fixedwing
DevDocs Autotune - fixedwing.md
DevDocs INAV PID Controller.md
DevDocs INAV_Wing_Tuning_Masterclass.pdf
DevDocs PID tuning.md
DevDocs Profiles.md

GPS

GPS and Compass setup
GPS Failsafe and Glitch Protection

OSD and VTx

DevDocs Betaflight 4.3 compatible OSD.md
OSD custom messages
OSD Hud and ESP32 radars
DevDocs OSD.md
DevDocs VTx.md

LED Strip

DevDocs LedStrip.md

ADVANCED

Advanced Tuning

Fixed Wing Autolaunch
DevDocs INAV_Autolaunch.pdf

Programming

DevDocs Programming Framework.md

Adjustments

DevDocs Inflight Adjustments.md

Mission Control

iNavFlight Missions
DevDocs Safehomes.md

Tethered Logging

Log when FC is connected via USB

Blackbox

DevDocs Blackbox.md
INAV blackbox variables
DevDocs USB_Mass_Storage_(MSC)_mode.md

CLI

iNav CLI variables
DevDocs Cli.md
DevDocs Settings.md

VTOL

DevDocs MixerProfile.md
DevDocs VTOL.md

TROUBLESHOOTING

"Something" is disabled Reasons
Blinkenlights
Pixel OSD FAQs
TROUBLESHOOTING
Why do I have limited servo throw in my airplane

ADTL TOPICS, FEATURES, DEV INFO

AAT Automatic Antenna Tracker
Building custom firmware
Default values for different type of aircrafts
Features safe to add and remove to fit your needs.
Developer info
INAV MSP frames changelog
INAV Remote Management, Control and Telemetry
Lightweight Telemetry (LTM)
Making a new Virtualbox to make your own INAV
MSP Navigation Messages
MSP V2
OrangeRX LRS RX and OMNIBUS F4
Rate Dynamics
Target and Sensor support
UAV Interconnect Bus
Ublox 3.01 firmware and Galileo
DevDocs 1wire.md
DevDocs ADSB.md
DevDocs Battery.md
DevDocs Buzzer.md
DevDocs Channel forwarding.md
DevDocs Display.md
DevDocs Fixed Wing Landing.md
DevDocs GPS_fix_estimation.md
DevDocs LED pin PWM.md
DevDocs Lights.md
DevDocs OSD Joystick.md
DevDocs Servo Gimbal.md
DevDocs Temperature sensors.md

OLD LEGACY INFO

Supported boards
DevDocs Boards.md
Legacy Mixers
Legacy target ChebuzzF3
Legacy target Colibri RACE
Legacy target Motolab
Legacy target Omnibus F3
Legacy target Paris Air Hero 32
Legacy target Paris Air Hero 32 F3
Legacy target Sparky
Legacy target SPRacingF3
Legacy target SPRacingF3EVO
Legacy target SPRacingF3EVO_1SS
DevDocs Configuration.md
Request form new PRESET
DevDocs Introduction.md
Welcome to INAV, useful links and products
iNav Telemetry
DevDocs Rangefinder.md
DevDocs Rssi.md
DevDocs Runcam device.md
DevDocs Serial.md
DevDocs Telemetry.md
DevDocs Rx.md
DevDocs Spektrum bind.md

Clone this wiki locally