Annoying links to original on scaled images

[txomon]

Subject: It's annoying to have all rescaled images linked to original one always

Problem

• If you rescale anything, even an icon, sphinx will generate a link to it

Procedure to reproduce the problem

Scale an image.

Expected results

Can we just add an option to image to avoid the generation of the link?

Environment info

• OS: Linux
• Python version: 3.6
• Sphinx version: latest
• html builder

I can make a PR, but just want confirmation that it would be accepted. Although maybe it exists already...

[tk0miya]

How about html_scaled_image_link?

[txomon]

I do want that pictures that are scaled actually have a link to originals, that's just fine. But there are small ones like icons etc that just don't make sense =)

…

On Sat, Nov 11, 2017, 08:34 Takeshi KOMIYA ***@***.***> wrote: How about html_scaled_image_link? — You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#4229 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAN7mvHp6QuQROx4wInBwMPtVOeGqM70ks5s1VwggaJpZM4QYh-B> .

[tk0miya]

Ah, I understand. sorry, html_scaled_image_link is not good.
Indeed, such a hyperlink is not needed. Yes, any contribution is always welcome :-)
I think no option is needed. It's reasonable behavior to me.

[txomon]

When you mean no option, you mean that no additional attribute for `..image::` is required? If so, what method for not generating the link do you propose?

…

On Sat, Nov 11, 2017, 12:20 Takeshi KOMIYA ***@***.***> wrote: Ah, I understand. sorry, html_scaled_image_link is not good. Indeed, such a hyperlink is not needed. Yes, any contribution is always welcome :-) I think no option is needed. It's reasonable behavior to me. — You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#4229 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAN7moS4zbQ7mTtY2E3IEmHCG6XF0FtDks5s1ZD6gaJpZM4QYh-B> .

[tk0miya]

AFAIK the thumbnail images are used only if users uses :scale:, :width: or :height: options for images. So it is possible to know the conversion is needed or not. I think a hyperlink is not needed for not converted images even if these options are specified.

[txomon]

Yes, my question is, how do we deactivate the hyperlink generation when those images are specified?

.. image:: something.jpg
   :scale: 50
   :nolink:

my proposal was to add an option, and you seemed to say that no option is needed, so I am asking what solution would you propose.

Sorry if I wasn't clear enough =)

[tk0miya]

Ah, sorry. I'd misunderstood your request. Okay, you'd like to disable hyperlinks of specific images, right?
I'd like to hear you why do you want to disable specific ones?

I think we have to be careful to add a new option by Sphinx to keep syntax simple. So I'd like to know the reason.

[txomon]

I'd like to hear you why do you want to disable specific ones?

It's part of the problem description when I opened the issue. It doesn't make sense to have a link in an icon.

Another alternative I had thought of was to put some null link or something in the link in the existing :target: option, but couldn't figure it out. I am really open to suggestions

[RGSchuster]

I may be too new to Sphinx, but could you add a feature, say html_icon_image_link that, when set to false, disables the post_process_images function for images below a certain size?

[txomon]

In my case it's just for specific images. I wouldn't do it also dependant on below a certain size, but just disabled by image. The use case is just for certain images, is not something general. I could have another image set to 50% scale and be an image I want a link for...

…

On Wed, Nov 15, 2017 at 6:03 PM RGSchuster ***@***.***> wrote: I may be too new to Sphinx, but could you add a feature, say html_icon_image_link that, when set to false, disables the post_process_images function for images below a certain size? — You are receiving this because you authored the thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#4229 (comment)>, or mute the thread <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AAN7mg-TxrFV2-6HaIOoGYRxzHRRSlecks5s2yeDgaJpZM4QYh-B> .

[tony]

I don't think html_scaled_image_link is sufficient because I want to preserve the link behavior by default. I want to opt-out of the link for scaled images.

So I like the :nolink: idea.

[mgeier]

👍 for the :nolink: option (or something similar)!

I've used the :width: and :height: option for reST content that is auto-generated by a Sphinx extension, where having a link to the full-sized image doesn't make sense (see spatialaudio/nbsphinx#226 and spatialaudio/nbsphinx#222).

However there may be user-generated reST pages in the same Sphinx project where the link indeed does make sense, so using html_scaled_image_link = False isn't really an option.

[jmckenna]

agreed with @txomon, we really need a :nolink: option for Sphinx image directives (I keep hitting this issue).

[tk0miya]

I added a new style option :class: no-scaled-link since Sphinx-2.4 (refs: #7032).
I think this issue was already fixed, right?

[mgeier]

Thanks @tk0miya!
I've used this in spatialaudio/nbsphinx#461 and it works great!

But are you sure about the version number 2.4?
AFAICT #7032 is available since Sphinx 3.0.0b1. Or am I missing something?
See #7062 (comment).

[jmckenna]

oh true @tk0miya confirmed, works great! (with 3.0.3) Sorry for my misunderstanding.

[tk0miya]

oh, sorry. It was released as 3.0. I saw wrongly the milestone of #7032.

[tk0miya]

Closing. Thank you for discussing!