Keeping original signatures for functions/methods

[shimizukawa]

I'm using Sphinx's autodoc feature to document my API.

Example:

#!python

DEFAULT_OPTION = 'default'
def do_something(msg, option=DEFAULT_OPTION):
    print msg

The generated documentation now shows the following signature:

do_something(msg, option='default')

It would be nice if there was a way to tell Sphinx to keep the name of the constant value, i.e.

do_something(msg, option=DEFAULT_OPTION)

At the moment the only alternative is to write all signature by hand again.

---

• Bitbucket: https://bitbucket.org/birkenfeld/sphinx/issue/759
• Originally reported by: Sebastian Rahlf
• Originally created at: 2011-08-31T11:29:50.797

[martinpengellyphillips]

+1

[hypnocat]

@shimizukawa,@martinpengellyphillips you may try my fork with this feature.
Install sphinx, and add to conf.py
autodoc_dumb_docstring = True
then rebuild docs. Feel free to msg me.

[mikofski]

Another alternative that would be nice and might work easily is to allow the user to specify the value of an argument instead of the entire signature.

• Unspecified arguments would be parsed by sphinx as usually.
• Only the specified arguments would be annotated differently.
• Omitting :annotation: would remove myarg from the signature so that it didn't show up at all as an interesting for secret optional args.
• Specifying blank :annotation: would omit the default altogether but the keyword argument would still show up, just with no default value.
• If myarg is not in the list of arguments parsed from the signature, then a warning is raised and the directive does nothing.
• Markup roles like :class:, :data:, etc. can be used to link to the specified default.
• If myarg is not a keyword argument, then should it warn or should it specify the default in defiance of all logic? probably warn.

For example, given the following mymodule.py file:

"""a module with special treatment of arguments"""

DEFAULT = "a very long value that I don't want to display in my function, class and method signatures"
"""a description of the default"""

def myfunc(args, myarg=DEFAULT, kwargs=None):
    """
    a function with an ugly default arg value

    :param args: some arguments
    :param myarg: a keyword arg with a default specified by a module constant
    :param kwargs: some keyword arguments
    """
    pass

class MyClass():
    """a class with an ugly default arg value in its constructor"""
    def __init__(self, args, myarg=DEFAULT, kwargs=None):
        pass
    def mymeth(self, args, myarg=DEFAULT, kwargs=None):
        """a method with an ugly default arg value"""
        pass

use mymodule.rst file with the following:

.. automodule:: mymodule

.. autodata:: DEFAULT
   :annotation: a default value

The value of ``myarg`` in this function is replaced by :data:`~mymodule.DEFAULT`

.. autofunction:: myfunc
   .. argument:: myarg
      :annotation: :data:`~mymodule.DEFAULT`

The value of ``myarg`` in this class constructor is not shown

.. autoClass:: MyClass
   :members:
   .. argument:: myarg
      :annotation:

The value of ``myarg`` in this class method is hidden

.. automethod:: MyClass.mymeth
   .. argument:: myarg

would output the following:

mymodule
a module with special treatment of arguments

mymodule.DEFAULT = 'a default value'
a description of the default

The value of myarg in this function is replaced by :data:~mymodule.DEFAULT

mymodule.myfunc(args, myarg=DEFAULT, kwargs=None)
a function with an ugly default arg value

Parameters

• args - some arguments
• myarg - a keyword arg with a default specified by a module constant
• kwargs - some keyword arguments

The value of myarg in this class constructor is not shown

mymodule.MyClass(args, myarg=, kwargs=None)
a class with an ugly default arg value in its constructor

The value of myarg in this class method is hidden

mymodule.MyClass.mymeth(args, kwargs=None)
a method with an ugly default arg value

[tk0miya]

Will be fixed by #8771. Closing.