Procedural geometry #65

thenuts · 2023-11-24T23:17:39Z

The Procedural geometry code example on my computer doesn't render color, just black geometry

VaclavElias · 2023-11-25T11:15:52Z

Could you tell us about your PC spec? What graphic card do you have?

VaclavElias · 2023-11-25T11:16:30Z

@dotlogix, would you have any ideas why is that?

thenuts · 2023-11-25T22:56:52Z

I am learning the internals of stride and trying to debug for more tips, but I am not very optimistic about my skill to do it.
Processor 12th Gen Intel(R) Core(TM) i7-12700 2.10 GHz
Installed RAM 32.0 GB (31.7 GB usable)
NVIDIA GeForce RTX 4060 Ti

thenuts · 2023-12-21T14:57:28Z

Any help on how can I verify what's is wrong here. I really want to work with Stride as a code-only solution for a simple game.

VaclavElias · 2023-12-21T15:09:27Z

Is your example on GitHub?

thenuts · 2023-12-21T15:11:36Z

yes, Example05_ProceduralGeometry

dotlogix · 2023-12-21T16:15:07Z

@VaclavElias sorry for the late response I was pretty busy in the last month and couldn't take a look.
Unfortunately, I am not able to reproduce this issue on my machine, both the Debug and Release versions work fine.

Could it be an issue with the backend? Not sure what graphics pipeline Nvidia uses by default as I am using an AMD 6700XT

dotlogix · 2023-12-21T16:19:59Z

@thenuts could you try as an experiment to change the IndexType from IndexingType.Int16 to IndexingType.Int32 ?
Maybe Nvidia does not like 16bit ints as indices, although it might be sth else if the geometry shows up correctly for you.

Maybe play around a bit with the data types for vertex colors.

Or another idea would be to try to explicitly set the color vertex stream in the material like so:

new MaterialInstance {
  Material = Material.New(graphicsDevice, new MaterialDescriptor {
      Attributes = new MaterialAttributes {
          DiffuseModel = new MaterialDiffuseLambertModelFeature(),
          Diffuse = new MaterialDiffuseMapFeature {
              DiffuseMap = new ComputeVertexStreamColor
              {
                  Stream = new ColorVertexStreamDefinition(0)
              }
          },
      }
  })
}

If nothing of this helps I am pretty much out of ideas as it seems to be a Stride issue then I guess.

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T19:56:04Z

I'm seeing the same problem. A few things to note:

Built with .NET SDK 8.0.100
Switching to IndexingType.Int32 did not help.
The shapes are only visible from one side. Moving the camera to see their backsides makes them disappear, but their shadows are still present.
Running it produced these warnings:

EXEC : warning 1.880s: [AssetCompiler] Could not find game settings asset at location [GameSettings]. Use a Default One
 [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\Example05_Proced
uralGeometry.csproj]
Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionRawAOEffect_0cc465504e487e664337c636d7346293.hlsl(222,11-59): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionRawAOEffect_0cc465504e487e664337c636d7346293.hlsl(222,11-59): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_e1ec59d32a8276ef3e5580b114564ebb.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_e1ec59d32a8276ef3e5580b114564ebb.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_0a3ade3eec873ffbb3eb696a546a7ec1.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_0a3ade3eec873ffbb3eb696a546a7ec1.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_SSLRCombinePass_408b7839b3d48902227979aa949fb79a.hlsl(248,5-15): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example05_ProceduralGeometry\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_SSLRCombinePass_408b7839b3d48902227979aa949fb79a.hlsl(248,5-15): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

System info:
OS: Windows 11 Pro version 10.0.22621 Build 22621
CPU: AMD Ryzen 5800X
GPU: NVIDIA RTX 3080 Ti
Graphics driver: Driver version 546.33

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T20:08:14Z

The shapes are only visible from one side. Moving the camera to see their backsides makes them disappear, but their shadows are still present.

That is probably normal behaviour. It does behave, even when you create your Mesh in Stride independently from this example. It behaves like that also on my example below..

Running it produced these warnings:

Are these showed only on the first run?

I am now experimenting with the library as you can see here and the Meshes are working..

https://github.com/stride3d/stride-community-toolkit/tree/main/examples/code-only/Example01_Basic2DScene

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T20:17:59Z

Running it produced these warnings:

Are these showed only on the first run?

The EXEC warning is shown each time. The others are only shown on the first run.

I am now experimenting with the library as you can see here and the Meshes are working..

This is how Example01 looks to me. Notice the black 2D squares.

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T20:19:26Z

Oh also, running Example01 produced these warnings.

C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Program.cs(171,13): warning CS8321: The local function 'AddSpriteBatchRenderer' is declared but never used [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\
code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(46,26): warning CS8602: Dereference of a possibly null reference. [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example0
1_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(61,9): warning CS8602: Dereference of a possibly null reference. [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01
_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(63,19): warning CS8602: Dereference of a possibly null reference. [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example0
1_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(49,13): warning CS0219: The variable 'textScale' is assigned but its value is never used [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\exam
ples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(16,35): warning CS8618: Non-nullable field '_sceneRenderer' must contain a non-null value when exiting constructor. Consider declaring the field as
 nullable. [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(17,31): warning CS8618: Non-nullable field '_ctx' must contain a non-null value when exiting constructor. Consider declaring the field as nullable.
 [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(13,22): warning CS0169: The field 'SpriteBatchRenderer._texture' is never used [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-
only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\SpriteBatchRenderer.cs(14,19): warning CS0414: The field 'SpriteBatchRenderer._fontSize' is assigned but its value is never used [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-commu
nity-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
EXEC : warning 1.594s: [AssetCompiler] Could not find game settings asset at location [GameSettings]. Use a Default One [C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\Example01_Basic2DScene.csproj]
Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionRawAOEffect_0cc465504e487e664337c636d7346293.hlsl(222,11-59): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionRawAOEffect_0cc465504e487e664337c636d7346293.hlsl(222,11-59): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_e1ec59d32a8276ef3e5580b114564ebb.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_e1ec59d32a8276ef3e5580b114564ebb.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_0a3ade3eec873ffbb3eb696a546a7ec1.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_AmbientOcclusionBlurEffect_0a3ade3eec873ffbb3eb696a546a7ec1.hlsl(223,19-130): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_SSLRCombinePass_408b7839b3d48902227979aa949fb79a.hlsl(248,5-15): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

Warning: C:\Users\binar\source\repos\stride-community-toolkit\examples\code-only\Example01_Basic2DScene\bin\Debug\net8.0\log\shader_SSLRCombinePass_408b7839b3d48902227979aa949fb79a.hlsl(248,5-15): warning X3206: implicit truncation of vector type

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T20:20:10Z

Interesting, as it affects also your 3D, what about Example2?

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T20:23:48Z

Same thing:

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T20:25:47Z

I see. We can ignore the warnings, as most likely they are not causing an issue. Also, the Mesh is most likely ok, as you have the problem generally. Not sure if there is not some issue with lighting, because you have some lights ok but the lights from the dark side are not working..

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T20:28:42Z

@Doprez, could it be the Light Probe issue?

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T20:35:01Z

This is now facing up, where the light is could you try that?

I changed some of these..

void GiveMeAPlane(MeshBuilder meshBuilder)
{
    meshBuilder.WithIndexType(IndexingType.Int16);
    meshBuilder.WithPrimitiveType(PrimitiveType.TriangleList);

    var position = meshBuilder.WithPosition<Vector3>();
    var color = meshBuilder.WithColor<Color>();

    meshBuilder.AddVertex();
    meshBuilder.SetElement(position, new Vector3(0, 1, 0));
    meshBuilder.SetElement(color, Color.Red);

    meshBuilder.AddVertex();
    meshBuilder.SetElement(position, new Vector3(1, 1, 0));
    meshBuilder.SetElement(color, Color.Green);

    meshBuilder.AddVertex();
    meshBuilder.SetElement(position, new Vector3(1, 1, 1));
    meshBuilder.SetElement(color, Color.Blue);

    meshBuilder.AddVertex();
    meshBuilder.SetElement(position, new Vector3(0, 1, 1));
    meshBuilder.SetElement(color, Color.Yellow);

    meshBuilder.AddIndex(0);
    meshBuilder.AddIndex(1);
    meshBuilder.AddIndex(2);

    meshBuilder.AddIndex(0);
    meshBuilder.AddIndex(2);
    meshBuilder.AddIndex(3);
}

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T20:46:57Z

No change, except for the direction that the plane is pointing.

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T20:53:57Z

Thanks for a screenshot. Hmm, I would need some more experienced dev to step in. Are you exploring only code-only or you are also using Stride Game studio. I wonder if you would have the same issue also there, or is it related only to code-only issue.

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T21:00:46Z

This seems to be happening both with code-only and with game studio. I copy-pasted some of the procedural geometry code into my game studio project and noticed that the plane it made was totally black. I then ran the original code-only example from GitHub and saw that everything was still black.

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T21:04:33Z

What about if you just drop a box to Game Studio, or run some existing Game Studio tutorials (https://doc.stride3d.net/latest/en/tutorials/csharpintermediate/index.html)? Are you having the same issue there? If yes, could you screenshot for us?

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T21:56:12Z

I have only seen the issue when using the community toolkit code.

Here is a screenshot from the PhysicsSample. You can see the cubes that come with it, plus 2 capsules that I dragged and dropped. One has no material, and the other has the built-in Materials/CubeMat material.

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T21:58:54Z

And do you use toolkit's NuGet or directly toolkit source code?

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T22:09:42Z

Both:

I copy-pasted some of the procedural geometry code into my game studio project and noticed that the plane it made was totally black.

The toolkit was definitely referenced as a NuGet package when I tried integrating it into my existing project.

I then ran the original code-only example from GitHub and saw that everything was still black.

The GitHub examples reference the Stride.CommunityToolkit project directly, but that in turn references the engine's NuGet packages. Not sure if that's relevant but just wanted to point it out.

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T22:12:58Z

We are referencing the same packages. I was wondering if some updates were made..

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T22:54:00Z

For what it's worth, I cannot reproduce the problem on my laptop. Its specs are:
OS: Windows 11 Home version 10.0.22631 Build 22631
CPU: Intel i7-1065G7
GPU: Intel Iris Plus Graphics
Graphics driver: Driver version 31.0.101.2125

VaclavElias · 2024-01-01T23:02:20Z

That is really a mystery!!🤦‍♂️Let's see if we can get some input from others.

RichardMelito · 2024-01-01T23:24:06Z

Could it be a problem with NVIDIA GPUs?

VaclavElias · 2024-01-02T23:56:43Z

It would be good to find out, if the issue is only happening when you are using the toolkit. The reason for that is that toolkit is in preview and I am trying to figure out the correct settings for the GraphicCompositor which might be affected by GPU.

This example #65 (comment), if you do it through Stride Studio, without any reference to the toolkit, does it also lose colours.

These are my steps I did through Stride Studio. If you can get the same result, it means the issue is in the toolkit. If not, then I don't know.

Create new project - New game template

Default settings left as it is

I added a cube without material

And this is the result, all good

RichardMelito · 2024-01-03T03:21:46Z

That works, so it seems like it's something in the community toolkit.

thenuts · 2024-01-03T03:48:24Z

It works for me also, but I think this is different; how can we create a ComputeVertexStreamColor from the editor?

VaclavElias · 2024-11-26T23:02:03Z

Hello. I hope everyone is good. I also experienced the same issue with my new PC! This time it was resolved with this PR #179. We think it might have been related with this issue.

The NuGet packages are not yet released. But you can use the source code to try it if you would like. Once the NuGet packages are out, I will close this issue as resolved.

VaclavElias added the p3 Medium priority, and does not prevent the core functionality label Feb 18, 2024

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Procedural geometry #65

Procedural geometry #65

thenuts commented Nov 24, 2023

VaclavElias commented Nov 25, 2023

VaclavElias commented Nov 25, 2023

thenuts commented Nov 25, 2023

thenuts commented Dec 21, 2023

VaclavElias commented Dec 21, 2023

thenuts commented Dec 21, 2023

dotlogix commented Dec 21, 2023

dotlogix commented Dec 21, 2023 •

edited

Loading

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024 •

edited

Loading

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024 •

edited

Loading

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024 •

edited

Loading

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 2, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 3, 2024

thenuts commented Jan 3, 2024

VaclavElias commented Nov 26, 2024

Procedural geometry #65

Procedural geometry #65

Comments

thenuts commented Nov 24, 2023

VaclavElias commented Nov 25, 2023

VaclavElias commented Nov 25, 2023

thenuts commented Nov 25, 2023

thenuts commented Dec 21, 2023

VaclavElias commented Dec 21, 2023

thenuts commented Dec 21, 2023

dotlogix commented Dec 21, 2023

dotlogix commented Dec 21, 2023 • edited Loading

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024 • edited Loading

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024 • edited Loading

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024 • edited Loading

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024

VaclavElias commented Jan 2, 2024

RichardMelito commented Jan 3, 2024

thenuts commented Jan 3, 2024

VaclavElias commented Nov 26, 2024

dotlogix commented Dec 21, 2023 •

edited

Loading

RichardMelito commented Jan 1, 2024 •

edited

Loading

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024 •

edited

Loading

VaclavElias commented Jan 1, 2024 •

edited

Loading