Component doesn't get removed in #each with no props/children

[jamesbirtles]

Repro: https://svelte.dev/repl/8d5bc96db7634fe0b898b6755b0e7b90?version=3.5.1

Hit the add button, works. Hit the remove button, it fails!

If you add any property to MyComp or give it children, then the remove button begins to work.

[usernamus]

You must use unique keys on list items so that Svelte knows which item to delete. Please, read this part of documentation for a better understanding: Svelte:each

Fix your code, show in 15 line: REPL

[usernamus]

@UnwrittenFun, not sure about the completeness of my previous comment. But this may be the solution

[Panya]

This case is broken in 3.5.2 even with unique keys (REPL). Try to click on the remove button.

[Rich-Harris]

The original issue is a bug — without a specified key, it should behave as though you'd done this:

{#each arr as item, i (i)}
	<MyComp />
{/each}

The keyed case is fixed in 3.5.3.

[Rich-Harris]

No idea how this bug survived in the wild so long. Fixed in 3.6.0