extremely slow builds / vercel crashes and fails to build our app

[zallarak]

Describe the feature you'd like to request

next.js version: 10.2.0

here is our next.js config

const withAntdLess = require("next-plugin-antd-less");
const nextConstants = require("next/constants");
const path = require("path");

const makeCommitSHA = () => {
  const {
    VERCEL_GITHUB_COMMIT_SHA,
    GITHUB_SHA,
    GCLOUD_COMMIT_SHA,
  } = process.env;
  return (
    GCLOUD_COMMIT_SHA || VERCEL_GITHUB_COMMIT_SHA || GITHUB_SHA || "unknown"
  );
};
const makeSentryReleaseID = () => {
  const {
    VERCEL_GITHUB_COMMIT_SHA,
    GITHUB_SHA,
    GCLOUD_COMMIT_SHA,
    SENTRY_RELEASE_ID,
  } = process.env;
  if (SENTRY_RELEASE_ID) {
    return SENTRY_RELEASE_ID;
  }
  if (GCLOUD_COMMIT_SHA) {
    return `gcloud-${GCLOUD_COMMIT_SHA || "unknown"}`;
  }
  if (VERCEL_GITHUB_COMMIT_SHA) {
    return VERCEL_GITHUB_COMMIT_SHA || "unknown";
  }
  if (GITHUB_SHA) {
    return GITHUB_SHA || "unknown";
  }
  return "unknown";
};

const sentryReleaseIDBase = `frontend@${makeSentryReleaseID()}`;
const shouldGenerateSourceMaps =
  process.env.SENTRY_AUTH_TOKEN && sentryReleaseIDBase !== "frontend@unknown";

module.exports = (phase) => {
  const config = withAntdLess({
    reactStrictMode: true,
    productionBrowserSourceMaps: shouldGenerateSourceMaps,
    compress: true,
    images: {
      domains: ["logo.clearbit.com"],
    },
    serverRuntimeConfig: {
      NODE_ENV: process.env.NODE_ENV,
      DOMAIN: process.env.DOMAIN,
      // Third-parties
      LOGROCKET_APP_ID: process.env.LOGROCKET_APP_ID,
      SEGMENT_WRITE_KEY: process.env.SEGMENT_WRITE_KEY,
      PLAID_ENV: process.env.PLAID_ENV,
      STRIPE_PUBLIC_KEY: process.env.STRIPE_PUBLIC_KEY,
      STRIPE_OAUTH_CLIENT_ID: process.env.STRIPE_OAUTH_CLIENT_ID,
      GOOGLE_MAPS_API_KEY: process.env.GOOGLE_MAPS_API_KEY,
      SENTRY_ENVIRONMENT: process.env.SENTRY_ENVIRONMENT,
      // optional
      MODE: process.env.MODE,
      FEATURE_FLAGS: process.env.FEATURE_FLAGS,
      SENTRY_DSN: process.env.SENTRY_DSN,
    },
    lessVarsFilePath: "./antdThemeVariables.less",
    webpack: (config, { isServer, webpack }) => {
      // sentry stuff
      // In `pages/_app.js`, Sentry is imported from @sentry/node. While
      // @sentry/react will run in a Node.js environment, @sentry/node will use
      // Node.js-only APIs to catch even more unhandled exceptions.
      //
      // This works well when Next.js is SSRing your page on a server with
      // Node.js, but it is not what we want when your client-side bundle is being
      // executed by a browser.
      //
      // Luckily, Next.js will call this webpack function twice, once for the
      // server and once for the client. Read more:
      // https://nextjs.org/docs/api-reference/next.config.js/custom-webpack-config
      //
      // So ask Webpack to replace @sentry/node imports with @sentry/react when
      // building the browser's bundle
      // and vice versa
      if (isServer) {
        config.resolve.alias["@sentry/react"] = "@sentry/node";
        config.resolve.alias["@sentry/node"] = "@sentry/node";
      } else {
        config.resolve.alias["@sentry/node"] = "@sentry/react";
        config.resolve.alias["@sentry/react"] = "@sentry/react";
      }

      // See: https://github.com/momopig/react-antd-icons
      config.resolve.alias["@ant-design/icons/lib"] = path.resolve(
        __dirname,
        "./styleMock.tsx"
      );

      config.plugins = config.plugins || [];

      // ignore calls to graphql
      config.plugins.push(
        new webpack.ProvidePlugin({
          graphql: "lodash/noop",
        })
      );

      if (phase === nextConstants.PHASE_PRODUCTION_BUILD) {
        const SENTRY_RELEASE_ID = `${sentryReleaseIDBase}${
          isServer ? "-server" : ""
        }`;

        // Sentry release ID should be hardcoded in the build
        config.plugins.push(
          new webpack.DefinePlugin({
            COMMIT_SHA: JSON.stringify(makeCommitSHA()),
            SENTRY_RELEASE_ID: JSON.stringify(SENTRY_RELEASE_ID),
          })
        );

        const { SENTRY_AUTH_TOKEN } = process.env;
        if (SENTRY_AUTH_TOKEN) {
          console.log(
            `Publishing sourcemaps to Sentry under release id ${SENTRY_RELEASE_ID}`
          );
          const SentryWebpackPlugin = require("@sentry/webpack-plugin");
          config.plugins.push(
            new SentryWebpackPlugin({
              // sentry-cli configuration
              authToken: SENTRY_AUTH_TOKEN,
              org: "pipe",
              project: "frontend",
              include: ".next",
              ignore: ["node_modules"],
              stripPrefix: ["webpack://_N_E/"],
              urlPrefix: `~/_next`,
              release: SENTRY_RELEASE_ID,
            })
          );
        }
        if (shouldGenerateSourceMaps) {
          // This lets Sentry have the sourcemaps without
          // exposing the URL of the source code to the client.
          // In production, we also delete sourcemaps.
          // TODO(igm): private server to host sourcemaps
          // See https://webpack.js.org/configuration/devtool/
          config.devtool = "hidden-source-map";
        }
      } else {
        // Default commit sha/sentry release ID for local dev
        config.plugins.push(
          new webpack.DefinePlugin({
            COMMIT_SHA: JSON.stringify("local-unknown"),
            SENTRY_RELEASE_ID: JSON.stringify("local-unknown"),
          })
        );
      }

      return config;
    },
    typescript: {
      // !! WARN !!
      // Dangerously allow production builds to successfully complete even if
      // your project has type errors.
      // !! WARN !!
      // this is OK because we have type checking in a GH action
      ignoreBuildErrors: true,
    },
    async redirects() {
      return [
        // vendor
        {
          source: "/",
          destination: "/inbox",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/link",
          destination: "/welcome",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/onboard",
          destination: "/welcome",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/settings/payments",
          destination: "/finance/lists/all-transactions",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/settings/payments/:paymentID",
          destination: "/finance/payouts/:paymentID",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/finance/payments",
          destination: "/finance/lists/all-payments",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/finance/payouts",
          destination: "/finance/lists/all-payouts",
          permanent: true,
        },

        // admin
        {
          source: "/admin/subscriptions",
          destination: "/admin/lists/create/subscriptionsv2",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/admin/users",
          destination: "/admin/lists/pipe-admin-users",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/admin/vendors",
          destination: "/admin/lists/create/vendors",
          permanent: true,
        },
        {
          source: "/admin/connectors",
          destination: "/admin/lists/create/connectors",
          permanent: true,
        },
      ];
    },
  });

  if (process.env.ANALYZE === "true") {
    const withBundleAnalyzer = require("@next/bundle-analyzer")({
      enabled: true,
    });
    return withBundleAnalyzer(config);
  }

  return config;
};

Describe the solution you'd like

help debugging or resolution - right now vercel is not usable and we must use google cloud

Describe alternatives you've considered

moving to react or using higher performance machines

[rauchg]

Would you mind turning off as many extensions as you can that don't involve breaking your app or having to modify it in a meaningful way, and reporting build times?

I'd suggest starting with source maps, which we have known to be problematic.

[timneutkens]

Can you try disabling productionSourceMaps and sentry-webpack-plugin

[sokra]

If this is related to the webpack build (not the static generation or typechecking) there is now a env variable you can set to get more insight into the build:

• NEXT_WEBPACK_LOGGING=1 prints some basic webpack information to the console, including build times for client and server builds.
• NEXT_WEBPACK_LOGGING=profile-client or NEXT_WEBPACK_LOGGING=profile-server or even NEXT_WEBPACK_LOGGING=profile-client,profile-server displays very detailed timing information of the webpack builds. Maybe put that into a gist and post it here so we can look into that.

Note: just seeing you are still on webpack 4, where this isn't available...

[zallarak]

Did the profiling and the verbose logging (NEXT_WEBPACK_LOGGING=profile-client,profile-server) as @sokra specified.

I did this on my extremely fast desktop (32gb ram, ryzen 5950x). Doing it on my laptop is substantially slower.

Profiles and logs:

• base (yes sourcemaps and yes sentry): 686.24s
  -- https://gist.github.com/zallarak/70c9a7570f5c13959332fddf885e2dca
• no sentry: 157.43s
  -- https://gist.github.com/zallarak/b416b814281bd09eac51142c44b7c3be
• no sentry and no sourcemaps: 64.47s
  -- https://gist.github.com/zallarak/43676425c8780d22649b3db9dfe52073

Some naive thoughts:

• Clearly, sentry adds a ton of time and from the live output, much of the time was spent uploading ~400mb worth of sourcemaps related code. Is there a way to perhaps push a build out and asynchronously do sourcemaps? There could be downsides to this.

[MohdAhmad1]

I have just cloned a project, done yarn install, and the first build takes more than 5 seconds, the next builds take 2-3 seconds.
In next js 10 it was faster

[lobsterkatie]

Hi, all. Sentry JS SDK maintainer here.

I checked out the logs (thanks, @zallarak!) and TL;DR, sourcemap upload is taking forever because more stuff is getting uploaded than necessary.

Because this is really an issue with our SDK, I've filed an issue in our repo with lots more detail (linked above). @sokra, @timneutkens, there are some questions there having to do with webpack and/or nextjs which might benefit from your expertise, if you wouldn't mind taking a look.

P.S. @zallarak - I notice in the logs that you're still using the @sentry/browser/@sentry/node combo. You might consider giving our new @sentry/nextjs SDK a try, as it's where fixes for this issue will land.

[zallarak]

Thanks @lobsterkatie , we switched to @sentry/nextjs along with upgrading next to 11 and webpack to 5. Will run more benchmarks soon to see the changes.

[HazAT]

Just for reference, please follow this issue (getsentry/sentry-javascript#3769) we are going to improve this.

[kamilogorek]

@zallarak can you please update our webpack plugin to 1.16.0 and post new logs? It should now include all necessary timings to see where the bottleneck is. Thanks!

[lobsterkatie]

FYI, all - 6.11.0 is out with this fix. I did some testing in my small example app, to see how many files would be uploaded under different scenarios, both under 6.10.0 and 6.11.0 (target: est means target: experimental-serverless-trace):

@sentry/nextjs 6.10.0              @sentry/nextjs 6.11.0

                   next 10, webpack 4

target: server - 90                target: server - 44
target: est - 86                   target: est - 40

                    next 10, webpack 5

target: server - 100               target: server - 36
target: est - 89                   target: est - 56

                    next 11, webpack 4

target: server - 90                target: server - 44
target: est - 86                   target: est - 40

                    next 11, webpack 5

target: server - 86                target: server - 36
target: est - 89                   target: est - 55

(In the above tests, I started with a clean slate each time. The change will be more dramatic for folks using next 10 and either running yarn build after yarn dev, or running yarn build multiple times, since next 10 doesn't nuke the .next folder in between builds, which can lead to a buildup of artifacts.)

Please give it a try and let me know how you do!

[UPDATE: If you've changed the default and don't suppress the SentryWebpackPlugin logs, under webpack 4 you may see an error about a missing file path. It's a false positive - nothing is actually broken. A fix for this is in the works.]

[zallarak]

We're on webpack 5 and that builds are going well. we upgraded to next 11 and webpack 5 at the same time, and in doing so changed the way we did sourcemap generation, so it's hard to say exactly which thing was slowing us down before. right now we're pretty sure our build time bottlenecks are due to some specific node_modules dependencies and not due to vercel.

[leerob]

Awesome @zallarak! Really glad updating to latest Next.js and webpack has improved things 😄

If you have further questions, please let us know!

[balazsorban44]

This issue has been automatically locked due to no recent activity. If you are running into a similar issue, please create a new issue with the steps to reproduce. Thank you.