Security of bsd-games and bsd-games-non-free
============================================

Some games maintain system-wide score files or logs, and need
appropriate privileges to write to these files.  They can get these
privileges by being installed setgid games, or through the files being
world writable.  If they do not have these privileges, they will run,
but fail to update the score files.  Most of the games were written at
a time when security was not considered important; therefore, making
games setgid has in the past meant that users can get a shell with gid
games, and possibly also get access to the accounts of other games
players by corrupting the score files.  (This will also apply to many
more modern games that are badly written.)

In version 2.2, security fixes from OpenBSD have been applied: most of
the games that have score files will open them on startup, and then
drop any setgid privileges completely (including the saved gid).  This
limits the effect of a cracked game to corruption of its score file.
It should be somewhat safer now to make games setgid games than in
versions 2.1 and earlier, but probably not completely safe; phantasia,
sail, rogue, hack and tetris do not currently handle their score files
in the above way, and so should be considered the most dangerous to
install setgid.  If you are auditing these games, phantasia, sail,
rogue, hack and tetris should be considered the most important to
audit.  In versions before 2.14, rogue had an exploitable buffer
overrun (see NetBSD Security Advisory 2002-021).

An effect of this security policy is that in some cases the score
files need to be world-readable so that they can be opened for reading
after the game has dropped privileges, or by a score file reading
program that was never privileged.  In versions before 2.10, the
phantasia "characs" file (containing passwords for phantasia
characters) was mistakenly made world readable.

You should, of course, only install the games setgid if this is in
line with system security policy.  Games should not be installed
setuid, since if a setuid game is cracked this allows games to be
replaced with trojans.  Games should not be installed setgid to a
system group such as "root" or "daemon".  In some environments, an
acceptable alternative may be not to give the games any special
privileges, but to put trusted users in the games group.

An option is to use the "dungeon master" dm to regulate games playing.
I believe this is safe; games that do not need to run setgid drop the
setgid privileges they get from dm on startup.  If dm is setgid, but
the games that access score files are not, then they will keep their
setgid privileges from dm; note that in this case it does not make
sense for dm to be setgid to some gid other than the one (normally
"games") with write access to the score files.

This package does not yet support security hardening by giving each
setgid game its own gid, but in some environments you may wish to do
this.

***********************************************************************
*                                                                     *
* DO NOT INSTALL ANY GAMES SETUID, ONLY SETGID.                       *
*                                                                     *
* INSTALLING GAMES SETGID GAMES MIGHT ENABLE TO GET SHELLS WITH GID   *
* GAMES.                                                              *
*                                                                     *
* WHERE GAMES READ A SCORE FILE, IF A USER CAN CORRUPT THIS FILE IT   *
* MIGHT IN SOME CASES MEAN THEY CAN GET ACCESS TO THE ACCOUNTS OF     *
* OTHER USERS PLAYING THAT GAME.                                      *
*                                                                     *
* IF IN DOUBT, CHOOSE THE DEFAULT OPTIONS FOR PERMISSIONS AND DO      *
* WITHOUT SCOREFILES.                                                 *
*                                                                     *
* THESE GAMES COME WITH NO WARRANTY.                                  *
*                                                                     *
***********************************************************************

If you are compiling these games on an operating system other than
Linux, be warned that they rely for their security on
"setregid(getgid(), getgid())" dropping all setgid privileges
permanently, _including the saved gid_.  On some operating systems
this may fail to drop the saved gid (and indeed such operating systems
may provide no way for a process not running as root to revoke
privileges permanently); in such a case, bugs in a game may provide
access to the games group rather than merely to to that game's score
file.

Joseph S. Myers
jsm@polyomino.org.uk



Local Variables:
mode: text
End: